484 - Rejected Ideas, Great Advice (Dojo Conversations Episode 149)
Some episodes are carefully planned… and some are rescued straight out of the garbage can.
This week, Andrew and Jim wrap up the year by rifling through the legendary “maybe later” pile – a collection of rejected ideas, abandoned plans, and almost-episodes that never quite made the cut.
What starts as reflection quickly turns into some surprisingly solid piping advice, mixed with the usual chaos.
Along the way, they tackle big questions about marching style, presentation in solo competition, and whether looking polished actually affects results. Then it’s down the rabbit hole with pressure variance testing, tuning by intuition, and why “trial and error” might still beat science when it comes to getting your pipes locked in.
It’s messy, honest, practical… and accidentally one of the most useful episodes of the year.
They also dig into why tradition still matters – from kilts and uniforms to parade culture – and finish with quickfire advice on keeping piping fun for kids, playing without pain, and building real fluency in embellishments.
Got a topic sitting in your “maybe later” pile? Drop it in the comments – we just might pull it out next episode.
Here’s what we cover this week:
00:00 – Intro & End of Year Reflections
04:50 – The “Maybe Later” Pile: Rejected Topics
07:50 – Marching in Solo Competition: Big Steps or Little Steps?
10:30 – Does Presentation Matter in Competition?
12:30 – How to Own Your Style & Marching Advice
13:45 – The Blow Trick (Pressure Variance Testing)
14:00 – Pressure Variance, Tuning & Trial and Error
22:00 – Tuning Philosophy: Guessing, Intuition & Learning
27:00 – Uniforms, Kilts & the Value of Tradition
31:00 – Parades, Outfits & Embracing the Ridiculous
34:00 – Quickfire: Keeping Piping Cool for Kids
35:00 – Quickfire: Avoiding Pain (Posture & Comfort)
37:00 – Quickfire: Embellishment Fluency & Building Blocks
38:30 – Rhythm, Gracenotes & Abstractions in Learning
39:30 – Wrapping Up & Looking Ahead