Pet Sitter Confessional

Have you ever thought about what happens to your business when you're ready to step away? In this episode, Erin Fenstermaker, certified exit planner and pet industry veteran, breaks down the key elements that make a pet business valuable and sellable. She discusses the importance of recurring revenue, documented systems, and building a team of employees over independent contractors. Erin also explains what EBITDA is, what influences it, and how emotional readiness impacts a successful exit. Whether you're brand new or 30 years in, this conversation offers a roadmap to long-term value and future-proofing your business. Main Topics Exit planning and unplanned events Employees vs independent contractors What makes a business transferable Understanding EBITDA and business valuation Emotional aspects of selling a business Main Takeaway: "Exit planning is simply good business strategy." Whether you're thinking of selling or not, building a business that can operate without you creates value, freedom, and peace of mind. From documented systems to employee-led teams, what you build today impacts your options tomorrow. Even if you never sell, you'll gain a stronger, more resilient business that supports your lifestyle. So don't wait until it's too late—start exit planning now, because it's really just smart strategy. About our guest: Erin Fenstermaker is a certified exit planner and business consultant with over 20 years of experience in the pet industry. Through her firm, EF Consulting, she helps pet service businesses improve their operations, convert from independent contractor models to employee-based teams, and prepare for acquisition or sale. Erin also works with larger pet product companies through Birdseye Advisory Group and brings deep knowledge of market trends, business valuation, and strategic growth. She's passionate about building sustainable, scalable businesses that are both profitable and people-centered. Links EARN 1 CEU for PSI or NAPPS Erinfenstermaker.com - Pet industry consultant & certified exit planner (CEPA) Check out our Starter Packs See all of our discounts! Check out ProTrainings Code: CPR-petsitterconfessional for 10% off 📞 Call us: (636) 364-8260 Follow us on: Instagram, Facebook, Twitter Email us at: [email protected] Full show notes and transcript Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by our guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of Pet Sitter Confessional, its hosts, or sponsors. We interview individuals based on their experience and expertise within the pet care industry. Any statements made outside of this platform, or unrelated to the topic discussed, are solely the responsibility of the guest. Sponsored by: ❤️ Our AMAZING Patreon Supporters Time to Pet Visit: https://timetopet.com/confessional Code: 50% off first 3 months Peaceful Pet Music - Calm Music for Pets 🎶💜 From peaceful melodies to soothing nature sounds, this channel is your go-to spot when your pet is anxious and you don't know where to turn.💜🐾 Subscribe now at https://www.youtube.com/@peacefulpetmusic

What if the key to protecting your business and sanity is actually learning to care less? In this episode, we share how our unorthodox Word of the Year—"care less"—helped us step back from constant urgency, emotional overload, and decision fatigue. We talk about naming our non-negotiables, especially around safety and standards, while letting go of guilt and overinvestment in pricing pushback, employee drama, and social media opinions. We walk through the practical tools we used, like decision deadlines, "good enough" standards, and release phrases that helped us move from dwelling to doing. By the end, we show how caring less about the wrong things made room for more joy, clarity, and confidence in our life and business. Main topics: Redefining what "care" means Combating decision fatigue with structure Setting firm non-negotiable standards Emotional detachment vs. apathy Making faster, value-driven decisions Main takeaway: "It's really important to recognize that caring more is not the same as caring well." In pet care, we're taught that the more we care, the better we are—but that mindset can quietly drive us straight into burnout. In this episode, we talk about how we learned to protect our emotional bandwidth by deciding what truly deserves our deepest care and what doesn't. We share how setting decision deadlines, naming our non-negotiables, and releasing imagined reactions from clients and employees changed how we lead. If you've ever felt crushed under the weight of caring about everything, this conversation will help you care well where it counts—and let the rest go. Links: Check out our Starter Packs See all of our discounts! Check out ProTrainings Code: CPR-petsitterconfessional for 10% off 📞 Call us: (636) 364-8260 Follow us on: Instagram, Facebook, Twitter Email us at: [email protected] Full show notes and transcript Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by our guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of Pet Sitter Confessional, its hosts, or sponsors. We interview individuals based on their experience and expertise within the pet care industry. Any statements made outside of this platform, or unrelated to the topic discussed, are solely the responsibility of the guest. Sponsored by: ❤️ Our AMAZING Patreon Supporters Pet Sitters Associates Visit: https://www.petsitllc.com Code: Confessional

Fear Free Certification for taking the 'pet' out of 'petrified'. Get 10% off the with promo code PSC10. What does it really mean to be Fear Free certified as a pet sitter or dog walker? In this episode, Collin talks with Melissa Spooner-Raymond, a licensed veterinary technician and veterinary behavior specialist with Fear Free, about practical ways to reduce fear, anxiety, and stress for pets in our care. They explore reading body language, setting realistic goals for each visit, and using "the three Fs"—food, fun, and favorites—to create positive associations. Melissa shares real-world scenarios, from cautious chows to under-socialized COVID pets, offering strategies for short visits and multi-staff teams. The conversation highlights how consistency, documentation, and collaboration with the pet's wider care team can transform both the pet's experience and the sitter's safety. Main topics: Reading and respecting pet body language Applying the "three Fs" to build trust Strategies for short, time-limited visits Multi-staff consistency and SOPs Collaborating with the pet's full care team Main takeaway: "Stop and assess and watch—what is that animal trying to communicate?" So often, our love for animals makes us want to rush in, but the best care starts with observation. Every ear twitch, tail flick, or subtle shift tells a story about how that pet is feeling. When we slow down, we can adapt our approach to meet them where they are—turning fear into trust. As pet sitters and dog walkers, we aren't just completing a task; we're building a relationship, one respectful moment at a time. About our guest: Melissa is a passionate and skilled professional with a rich background in the animal care industry. Her experience spans general veterinary medicine, behavioral specialty medicine, and nonprofit organizations, where she has held a variety of roles supporting pets and their people. She holds an Associate of Applied Animal Science and is a Veterinary Technician Specialist in Behavior, a Certified Training Partner through Karen Pryor Academy, an Elite Fear Free Certified Veterinary Professional, and a TAGteach Certified Practitioner. Driven by a deep commitment to making a difference, Melissa strives to create meaningful, positive impacts for animals and their human companions through education and advocacy in veterinary behavior and training. Links: Get 1 CEU Fear Free Certification for taking the 'pet' out of 'petrified'. Get 10% off the with promo code PSC10. Fear Free Pets: https://fearfreepets.com Check out our Starter Packs See all of our discounts! Check out ProTrainings Code: CPR-petsitterconfessional for 10% off 📞 Call us: (636) 364-8260 Follow us on: Instagram, Facebook, Twitter Email us at: [email protected] Full show notes and transcript Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by our guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of Pet Sitter Confessional, its hosts, or sponsors. We interview individuals based on their experience and expertise within the pet care industry. Any statements made outside of this platform, or unrelated to the topic discussed, are solely the responsibility of the guest. Sponsored by: ❤️ Our AMAZING Patreon Supporters Time to Pet Visit: https://timetopet.com/confessional Code: 50% off first 3 months Pet Perennials Visit: https://petperennials.com/pages/register-for-a-business-account Code: 'PSC' when registering for a $2 off coupon on any purchases in the 1st 90 days

What do you do when your pet care business feels stuck in the same old patterns? In this episode, we talk about how "ruts" form in our businesses the same way they do on a muddy trail—through repeated, unexamined habits over time. We explain the brain science behind habitual neural pathways, how stress and burnout make ruts deeper, and why comfort and fear of change keep us on the same path. We then walk through the three biggest rut zones for pet sitters and dog walkers: marketing, services, and admin overload, with practical questions to help you spot where you're stuck. Finally, we share simple experiments and the importance of revisiting your purpose so you can start building new paths that actually fit the business and life you want today. Main topics: How business ruts quietly form Brain science behind habits Marketing ruts and client behavior Service evolution and client expectations Admin overload and survival mode Main takeaway: "Great businesses don't sit in ruts. They have to adapt." If your pet care business looks and runs exactly like it did five or ten years ago, this episode is your invitation to pause and take a fresh look. We talk about how ruts form in your marketing, your services, and your admin systems—often because your brain is tired, stressed, or simply clinging to what's familiar. You'll hear practical, low-pressure ideas for trying one new thing this week, plus questions to help you decide if you'd build your business the same way today. Most importantly, we'll help you reconnect with your purpose so you're not just surviving the busy seasons, but shaping a business that actually fits your life now. Links: Check out our Starter Packs See all of our discounts! Check out ProTrainings Code: CPR-petsitterconfessional for 10% off 📞 Call us: (636) 364-8260 Follow us on: Instagram, Facebook, Twitter Email us at: [email protected] Full show notes and transcript Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by our guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of Pet Sitter Confessional, its hosts, or sponsors. We interview individuals based on their experience and expertise within the pet care industry. Any statements made outside of this platform, or unrelated to the topic discussed, are solely the responsibility of the guest. Sponsored by: ❤️ Our AMAZING Patreon Supporters Pet Sitters Associates Visit: https://www.petsitllc.com Code: Confessional

How do you protect your passion while running a growing pet care business? In this episode, Wayne Hartley Jr. of Happy Hearts Pet Care and PETLANTA shares the realities of entrepreneurship, including the hustle, the overwhelm, and the habits that help keep you grounded. He discusses the role of community and education in sustainable growth, and why posting imperfect content is often better than not posting at all. Wayne opens up about learning from mistakes, setting boundaries, and shifting from surviving to scaling. His insights will inspire pet pros to lead with intention, not exhaustion. Main topics: Social media strategy and mindset Client education and trust-building Delegation and team development Managing overwhelm and time Hustle vs. sustainable growth Main takeaway: "I have to get out of the 'I have to' mindset and into the 'I get to' mindset." This shift changes everything. Instead of dreading tasks or feeling buried under responsibilities, Wayne Hartley Jr. reminds us to view our work as an opportunity. You get to grow a business. You get to care for pets. You get to make a difference. When we lead with gratitude and purpose, we show up better for our clients, our teams, and ourselves. Let's not forget—we built this on purpose. Now let's enjoy the privilege of doing the work. About our guest: Wayne Hartley Jr. is the owner of Happy Hearts Pet Care in Atlanta, Georgia, offering grooming, boarding, daycare, training, and retail services. He's also the founder of PETLANTA, a nonprofit that connects pet professionals through education, events, and fundraising. Through the Pet X Network, Wayne shares resources and conversations to uplift the pet care industry. Passionate about community building and professional growth, Wayne leads with the belief that better businesses are built together. Links: Happy Hearts Pet Care: https://www.instagram.com/happyheartspetcareatl PETLANTA (Nonprofit): https://www.instagram.com/petlanta.inc Pet X Network & Podcast: https://www.thepetxnetwork.com PetLanta: https://www.petlanta.org Previously on 375: https://www.petsitterconfessional.com/episodes/375 224: https://www.petsitterconfessional.com/episodes/224 Check out our Starter Packs See all of our discounts! Check out ProTrainings Code: CPR-petsitterconfessional for 10% off 📞 Call us: (636) 364-8260 Follow us on: Instagram, Facebook, Twitter Email us at: [email protected] Full show notes and transcript Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by our guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of Pet Sitter Confessional, its hosts, or sponsors. We interview individuals based on their experience and expertise within the pet care industry. Any statements made outside of this platform, or unrelated to the topic discussed, are solely the responsibility of the guest. Sponsored by: ❤️ Our AMAZING Patreon Supporters Time to Pet Visit: https://timetopet.com/confessional Code: 50% off first 3 months Pet Perennials Visit: https://petperennials.com/pages/register-for-a-business-account Code: 'PSC' when registering for a $2 off coupon on any purchases in the 1st 90 days