The Unconventional Soldier

CONTENT

The guests today are Neale Smiles a former soldier now working in the defence industry and Wilf Owen also a former soldier and author of the book "Euclid's Army: Preparing Land Forces for Warfare Today." The conversation focuses on modern military doctrine, training, and equipment for Western armies, particularly challenging traditional assumptions about land warfare. Key topics include the necessity of rigorous training to build soldier resilience and the evolving role of the infantryman as a "sensor" on the modern battlespace. We explore other issues such as the affordability and future utility of main battle tanks, deficiencies in current close combat fire support, and the crucial, yet often overlooked, logistical challenges posed by field hospital deployment.

WHERE TO GET OUR DESERT ISLAND DITS BOOK CHOICES

CONTENT

The guest today is former British Army officer Rob McAllister who discusses his military career with a focus on his challenging early life with dyslexia and his eventual decision to join the Royal Logistic Corps, after a period of academic and professional frustration. The conversation centres on his deployment to Afghanistan as a young second lieutenant commanding Combat Logistic Patrols, a role for which he received minimal preparation and was often responsible for large convoys of many vehicles and up to 120 soldiers resupplying British operating bases. Rob recounts the evolution of threats from direct contacts to IEDs , the inadequacies of early equipment and vehicles, and the immense responsibility placed on young officers and NCOs. He concludes with reflections on leadership, risk management, and the crucial importance of cultural awareness gained from his experiences.

Rob's book choice on Desert Islands Dits is "The Changing of the Guard: the British Army since 9/11" by Simon Akam. The team's choices are "Defeat Into Victory" by Field Marshal Viscount Slim and "War" by Sebastian Junger.

WHERE TO GET OUR DESERT ISLAND DITS BOOK CHOICES

CONTENT

The guest today is Barry Nisbet who joined the Canadian Forces in 1997. He completed RCR battle school graduating at the top of his class and was posted to the 1 Royal Canadian Regiment in Petawawa. In 2003 he completed U.S. Army Ranger School. He deployed to Kosovo in 1999 and Bosnia in 2003 as a rifleman. His first tour to Afghanistan was to Kabul in 2005. In 2006 he deployed to Kandahar as a sniper, call sign 63C, taking part in Operation Medusa. He received the Chief of Defence Staff Commendation for professionalism and leadership while rendering first aid to a severely injured soldier, 1 RCR Battle Group, Joint Task Force Afghanistan, 11 January 2007. Barry taught on multiple basic sniper courses in Petawawa training soldiers from the 1st and 3rd RCR Battalions and Canadian Special Operations Regiment. He returned to Afghanistan in 2010 as a Sniper Detachment Commander, call sign 66A, this was his 5th and final deployment before retiring as a Sergeant in 2012.

We discuss his path to becoming a sniper including the demanding sniper selection and training course and his experience as the first Canadian corporal to pass US Army Ranger School. Barry talks about the evolving tactics and operational realities of sniper teams in Afghanistan and reflects on the personal impact of combat. We finish off discussing the book he wrote with two other snipers Gordon Cullen and Mir Bahmanyar "Send It: Canada's Snipers at War in Afghanistan."

Barry's book choice on Desert Islands Dits is "The SAS Survival Handbook" by John "Lofty" Wiseman. My choice is Barry's Book "Send It: Canada's Snipers at War in Afghanistan."

CONTENT

In today’s episode, I’m joined by Andy, a former officer of the Royal Ulster Constabulary. Who deployed to Kosovo with the RUC as part of the UN international peacekeeping mission. His unique perspective offers a window into what it was like to move from a domestic conflict in the UK to an international operation in the Balkans, and the challenges of maintaining law, order, and stability in the aftermath of war. 

If you are interested in more episodes about the RUC Andy appeared on podcast 44 when he discussed his time in the force and service in the RUC specialist surveillance unit E4A.

By the late 1990s, the Balkans had descended into some of the worst violence Europe had witnessed since 1945. Years of ethnic and political tension culminated in the Kosovo conflict, which broke out in February 1998 and continued until June 1999. The fighting pitted the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia—then in control of Kosovo—against the Kosovo Liberation Army, an ethnic Albanian separatist force. The war was characterised by atrocities including ethnic cleansing, large-scale killings, and the forced displacement of hundreds of thousands. Scenes of burning villages and endless refugee columns dominated international news, prompting NATO intervention and ultimately leading to the withdrawal of Yugoslav troops.

However, the end of open hostilities marked the start of a new and complex phase. A vast international peacekeeping and reconstruction effort followed, with NATO’s KFOR, the United Nations, and numerous aid agencies attempting to restore order and stability. Those deployed—soldiers, police, and civilian workers alike—faced shattered infrastructure, volatile armed groups, traumatised populations, and the constant fear that violence could flare again at any moment.

Andy's book choice on Desert Islands Dits is "A Time to Stand; The Epic of The Alamo" by Walter Lord. My choice is "How Can Man Die Better - The Secrets of Isandlwana Revealed" by Mike Snook.

WHERE TO GET OUR DESERT ISLAND DITS BOOK CHOICES

CONTENT

My guest is former Army Reserve infantry soldier Matt Okuhara, whose story highlights the often-overlooked role of Britain’s reservists in war. After joining the TA while working in banking, Matt was mobilised for Operation TELIC 4 and deployed to Basra, Iraq. He shares the realities of pre-deployment training, patrolling under constant threat of IEDs and militia attacks, and the contact that changed everything.

We also discuss the challenges of returning to civilian life, the loss of comrades, and how he channelled his experiences into writing Basra and Back: The Memoir of an Infantryman in the Iraq War.

On Desert Island Dits, Matt chooses A Thousand Shall Fall by Murray Peden, while I select his own book, Basra and Back.

WHERE TO GET OUR DESERT ISLAND DITS BOOK CHOICES