Gay Music: In the Key of Q

For decades, queer people have been told that acceptance comes with conditions - be more normal, more mainstream, more palatable. But a new generation of queer artists is rejecting these expectations entirely. This fourth and final summer special examines how queer voices are choosing authentic expression over respectability politics, even when it comes at real costs.

Featuring conversations with Brendan Maclean from Australia, whose explicit "House of Air" video became his most radical artistic statement; Warren Dumas from Atlanta, who challenges gender expectations through androgynous presentation; SADBOY from New York, who highlights the contradiction between queer influence on culture and its lack of recognition; and Matt Fishel from the UK, who faced industry pressure to hide his gay identity but chose to create the representation he never had growing up.

These artists understand that visibility itself is activism, and that real change comes from refusing to apologise for who you are.

Timestamped Takeaways

01:48 - Brendan Maclean's radical response to respectability politics: "We created the most queer, joyful, unashamed music video I think that's ever existed"

06:26 - Warren Dumas on challenging expectations: "If it makes someone wonder, or if it makes someone stop... it opens up their mind to possibilities of being"

08:15 - SADBOY on queer influence without recognition: "We influence hip hop... The world does not spin without the black gaze"

11:41 - Matt Fishel on industry pressure: "Every single one of them basically said to me... you got to cut the gay content"

13:43 - Warren Dumas on gender double standards: "When you know there are female singers... can display these acts of homosexuality, and it's art. But once a male does it..."

15:16 - Brendan Maclean on career consequences: "It also really spoke to me away from pop music at the time... I went deeply inwards, as deep inwards as I possibly could go"

20:12 - Brendan on finding his way back: "I had to get back on at a drag night... and the next week I was in Italy performing for Bulgari in a castle"

21:01 - SADBOY's mission: "I'm trying to say that it's okay to display emotion... Any type of emotion like it's okay to love and to embrace that love"

23:32 - Matt Fishel on creating representation: "I made these songs for 15 year old me... This is the album I wanted to hear at 15 years old"

Links

Summary

This special episode brings together five queer musicians reflecting on how music shaped their identities and artistic paths. From Aruan's transformative encounter with Soft Cell on Top of the Pops in 1981 to SADBOY's mission to normalise emotional expression in Black masculinity, each artist reveals how music provided both refuge and resistance.

The conversation spans continents and generations, weaving together stories of discovery, survival, and ultimately creation. Whether it was Brendan Maclean finding salvation in high school musical theatre, Paul Andrews learning harmony from songbooks, or JSky recording tracks on a PlayStation, these artists demonstrate how queer people have always found ways to decode, create, and claim space through music.

Timestamped Takeaways

• [00:01:26] Soft Cell's Tainted Love awakens queer possibility: Aruan recalls being terrified and fascinated by Marc Almond's androgynous performance in 1981
• [00:02:30] Musical theatre becomes a lifeline: Brendan Maclean discovers "the brightest, shiniest version" of himself through performance
• [00:05:01] Afrofuturism meets family musical heritage: SADBOY describes growing up surrounded by house, hip hop, neo soul and electronic sounds
• [00:05:50] Weekly record shopping creates musical foundation: Paul Andrews' mother would sing songs to record store staff to find the right 45s
• [00:12:09] Prince models gender fluidity and rebellion: Aruan finds life-saving escapism in Prince's androgynous high-heeled defiance
• [00:13:43] From remixing Madonna to finding authenticity: Paul Andrews discusses working on "Ghost Town" and creating his own album
• [00:15:04] PlayStation production to professional recording: JSky's DIY journey from making beats on Music 2000 to booking studio time at 14
• [00:16:16] Decoding hidden queer messages in mainstream music: Brendan explains how queer audiences find Easter eggs and codes in songs
• [00:20:25] Hip hop as emotional revolution: SADBOY challenges hypermasculinity in Black communities through vulnerable music
• [00:21:32] The politics of pronouns in pop: Paul Andrews argues for authentic representation in lyrics to normalise queer love
• [00:22:24] Gay semiotics sparks creative breakthrough: Brendan's discovery of a book in a London sex shop leads to artistic revelation
• [00:23:43] Independence enables authentic expression: JSky celebrates not needing anyone's permission to create and release music

Links

Faith and family can be anchors in a young life — or weights that threaten to pull us under. In this summer special of In the Key of Q, I revisit remastered episodes from four remarkable queer artists: JSky (UK), Ty McKinnie (US), Blake Mundell aka Courier (US), and Wuhryn Dumas (US). Each speaks candidly about growing up queer in environments steeped in religious expectation and traditional family roles.

We hear how early love for music and community often existed alongside fear, shame, or silence, and how each of them has reclaimed their space in ways that honour both their identity and personal history. From Blake’s candid account of conversion therapy to Wuhryn’s reflections on becoming the role model he never had, these conversations challenge the idea that faith and queerness cannot coexist. Instead, they reveal the messy, human process of reconciling the two.

It’s an episode about reclaiming joy, asserting self-worth, and finding home, whether that's in a church, a studio, or simply in one’s own skin.

Timestamped Takeaways

• [00:00] Setting the stage: Introduction to the summer specials and the theme of faith and family for queer people.
• [00:01] Ty’s Hallelujah baby years: Early joy in church life and music, before acceptance came with conditions.
• [00:02] Blake’s nightly prayers: Internalising shame from evangelical messages, leading to years of self-questioning.
• [00:03] Wuhryn’s early queerness: Family members naming his queerness before he understood it himself.
• [00:05] JSky’s dual worlds: Balancing football culture with the joy of church music and his Nana’s influence.
• [00:09] The false choice: Blake describes feeling forced to choose between being queer or Christian.
• [00:11] Unsafe at home: Ty recalls retreating from family conversations about sexuality and Proposition 8.
• [00:12] Direct confrontation: JSky’s honest exchange with his religious grandmother sparks perspective change.
• [00:17] Reclaiming the sacred: Blake holds space for all his past selves; Ty builds new understanding with family.
• [00:21] Hugging on your own terms: Ty insists on physical affection despite discomfort.
• [00:21] Becoming the representation: Wuhryn’s commitment to showing young queer Black boys that they can thrive.
• [00:24] Home you build: Closing reflections on finding sacred space beyond traditional institutions.

Guest Bio

This special episode weaves together the experiences of five queer artists who've navigated the exhausting terrain between authentic self and performed safety. From Matt Fishel's childhood joy being "bullied out" of him to Blake Mundell's voluntary enrollment in conversion therapy, these stories map the psychological geography of concealment.

Each artist reveals how constant self-monitoring becomes second nature - whether it's Ty McKinnie learning not to talk with his hands or Vincent di Geronimo facing daily violence in small-town Connecticut. Yet these aren't simply survival stories. They're testimonies to the peculiar alchemy that transforms hidden pain into visible art, showing how queer resilience isn't about overcoming but about finding unexpected pathways through.

Timestamped Takeaways

• [00:01:33] Childhood transformation: Matt Fishel recalls when joy turned to vigilance at age 11
• [00:02:56] Geographic isolation: Vincent di Geronimo's move from NYC to Connecticut brings immediate violence
• [00:05:37] Performative masculinity: Blake Mundell maintains image through sports and "manly" activities
• [00:06:44] Accidental outing: Aruan's preference for Wham! over Madness exposes him in classroom
• [00:10:57] Physical withdrawal: Matt Fishel becomes recluse after serious beating in Nottingham
• [00:11:57] Conversion therapy: Blake voluntarily enrolls seeking to eliminate "sinful desires"
• [00:13:42] Suicide attempt: Blake's confidential letter to pastor gets weaponised by church
• [00:19:06] Classroom cruelty: Vincent faces normalised homophobia in maths class
• [00:20:15] Body language policing: Ty McKinnie's father forbids talking with hands
• [00:21:43] Unexpected liberation: Blake finds freedom through telling friend's story
• [00:24:23] Musical salvation: Aruan discovers community through Prince and Bowie
• [00:26:37] Industry rejection: Matt Fishel told by labels to "cut the gay content"

Guest Bio

This special episode features five remarkable artists from the podcast's first season in 2021: UK-based Matt Fishel and Aruan, alongside US artists Vincent di Geronimo, Blake Mundell (performing as Courier), and Ty McKinnie. Each brings their unique perspective on navigating queer identity through music.

Resource List

Summary

Eric Terino returns to share how much has shifted since his last appearance nearly two years ago. The American singer-songwriter opens up about recent breakthroughs in managing his agoraphobia, the political climate's impact on queer safety, and his evolution from punk minimalism to avant-garde folk electronica.

His latest release, Indelible Sundries, represents a bold artistic statement—a live album recorded remotely during isolating times, featuring hand-curated audience applause and single-take performances. Eric discusses the profound loss of his best friend, the healing power of authentic representation, and why he refuses to conform to stereotypical LGBTQ+ musical imagery.

Timestamped Takeaways

[00:29] Welcome Back: Eric discusses the strange experience of hearing his previous episode after a two-year delay

[04:33] Personal Evolution: How Eric has changed from his hopeful pandemic-era self to navigating current challenges

[09:15] Agoraphobia Breakthroughs: Recent progress in traveling beyond his comfort zone for the first time since the pandemic

[10:54] Political Climate Impact: How America's hostile environment toward minorities affects mental health and personal safety

[12:39] Musical Genre Evolution: The journey from minimalist punk to avant-garde folk electronica

[17:45] Grief as Creative Catalyst: Processing the loss of a lifelong friend and its impact on artistic depth

[21:02] Authentic LGBTQ+ Representation: Refusing to conform to stereotypical gay musician imagery

[23:11] Queercore Influences: Discussion of punk's inherently queer nature and the UK's 1990s Queercore movement

[26:21] Live Album Vulnerability: The courage required to create Indelible Sundries as a remote live recording

[28:01] Creative Process Innovation: How individual applause recordings and single takes created authentic live atmosphere

[34:22] Sandy Denny Cover Choice: Why "No More Sad Refrains" perfectly captured overcoming winter into spring

Guest Bio