The OSCARS: What Were They Thinking?!

Atomic Entertainment

Details

Ever watched the Academy Awards and thought, What were they thinking? You’re not alone. Join legendary comedian and writer of over 25 Oscar telecasts, Bruce Vilanch, and screenwriter/film nerd Adam “Tex” Davis (Just Friends) as they dive into Oscar history, unpacking the flubs, snubs, and surprises from Hollywood’s biggest night. From behind-the-scenes stories of A-list stars to insider insights on how the nominations and winners are really chosen, Bruce and Tex break down each Oscar ceremony year by year to reveal what the Academy got right—and what they didn’t. If you’ve ever questioned why your favorite movie or actor got overlooked, this podcast is for you. The Oscars: What Were They Thinking? Did you know that two of the Top 100 American Films of All-Time came out the same year but weren’t even nominated for an Academy Award? Or that the film often cited as the ‘Greatest Film of All Time’ didn’t win the Oscar in its year? Or that Cuba Gooding Jr. has the same number of acting Oscars as Al Pacino? Look, stuff happens. But if you’ve ever watched or read about the Academy Awards, you’ve probably been left scratching your head over which movies and performers won – and how many beloved films weren’t even considered. Why do so many Best Picture winners become some of the least remembered movies? How is it that legendary directors like Stanley Kubrick never won an Oscar? And why do great actors miss out on their best performances, only to win later for less impressive work? Sure, the Oscars aren’t sports – there’s no scoreboard to show the winners. But with so many Academy members voting, you’d think they’d get it right. Spoiler alert: They often don’t. On The Oscars: What Were They Thinking?, Bruce Vilanch and Adam “Tex” Davis take a deep dive into Oscar history, looking back at the biggest mistakes, controversies, and snubs. From Shakespeare in Love beating Saving Private Ryan to Dances with Wolves winning over Goodfellas, we’ll examine where the Academy went wrong. Along the way, you’ll hear incredible behind-the-scenes stories and never-before-told moments from Hollywood’s biggest night. We’re re-examining each Oscar ceremony, year-by-year, award-by-award, to see what the Academy got right, what they missed, and how we would “fix” the Oscars. Whether you’re a dedicated movie buff or just a casual fan, this is the podcast for you. Join us for The Oscars: What Were They Thinking?, where we break down the flubs, snubs, and forgotten gems of Oscar history.

Recent Episodes

NOV 16, 2026
1956 - A Marty Supremely Strange Oscars
Hey Oscar fans, welcome to the 1956 Oscars for the films of 1955. As Bruce and “Tex” discover, this was a pretty amazing year for movies and a really curious year for Oscar nominations and winners. At nearly every turn their is a surprise or head-scratching decision. And then, even when you sort of see where they’re going with things, they still manage to throw in a curveball or six. Besides the fun of dissecting this odd-ball Oscars, is the pleasure of getting to talk about so many different kinds of movies, many of which you may not have seen or even heard of. So this is a great one for picking up some new films to add to your watchlist, and hearing about some you might want to avoid! As always thanks for listening and geeking out to movies & The Oscars with us! Movies Discussed A Bullet for Joey A Man Called Peter Bad Day at Black Rock Blackboard Jungle Brief Encounter Caged Cat on a Hot Tin Roof Champion Confidential Report Days of Wine and Roses Detective Story Diabolique Doctor Zhivago Duel in the Sun East of Eden Gentleman's Agreement Great Expectations Guys and Dolls I'll Cry Tomorrow Interrupted Melody It's Always Fair Weather Julie Killer's Kiss Kiss Me Deadly Love Is a Many-Splendored Thing Love Letters Love Me or Leave Me Love with the Proper Stranger Marty Mister Hulot's Holiday Mister Roberts Mon Oncle Oklahoma! Pete Kelly's Blues Picnic Playtime Queen Bee Rebel Without a Cause Rififi Rome, Open City Sayonara Some Came Running Summertime Sweet Bird of Youth The Big Combo The Bridges at Toko-Ri The Court-Martial of Billy Mitchell The Golden Coach The Great Escape The Italian Job The Lost Weekend The Man from Laramie The Man Who Knew Too Much The Man with the Golden Arm The Night of the Hunter The Phenix City Story The Rose Tattoo The Seven Little Foys To Catch a Thief Trial Violent Saturday West Side Story Wild Is the Wind Women's Prison Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
82 MIN
OCT 19, 2026
Bonus Episode - The Oscars vs Sci-Fi Movies
Hey Oscar fans! One thing we’ve noticed in making this show is how few Science Fiction Films win Oscars. In fact, only ONE indisputable Sci-Fi film has ever won Best Picture! And it took over 42 years for the Academy to even nominate a Sci-Fi film! In this bonus episode, “Tex” and Mark run down the science fiction films that were nominated (for BP and Best Director) and lost; and more importantly which great Sci-Fi films were overlooked completely. Along the way, we make the case whether or not there is genre bias against Sci-Fi and if the Oscars have finally come around on recognizing science fiction for more than just technical awards. Either way, we discuss a ton of movies (listed below) for you to check out or revisit. Enjoy and thanks for listening! Sci-Fi Films Mentioned Everything, Everywhere, All at Once The Shape of Water Star Wars Frankenstein Ex-Machina Annihilation Them! Godzilla Mad Max: Fury Road Dune Pt. One Dune Pt. Two Terminator Terminator 2 Alien Aliens The Matrix Blade Runner Blade Runner 2049 A Clockwork Orange Close Encounters of the Third Kind ET Jurassic Park Avatar District 9 Inception Gravity Her The Martian Interstellar Arrival Black Panther Avatar: The Way of Water Don’t Look Up Poor Things Metropolis The Day the Earth Stood Still 2001 A Space Odyssey Planet of the Apes The Empire Strikes Back Back to the Future Brazil 12 Monkeys Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind Children of Men Tenet Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde Charley Starman Cocoon The Fly Moon Edge of Tomorrow Melancholia Star Trek 2: The Wrath of Kahn Galaxy Quest Primer Coherence Time Crimes The Man From Earth Safety Not Guaranteed The One I Love Gattaca Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
65 MIN