Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes Present

Jenn Fessler is joined by A Killer Story director Matthew Galkin and executive producer Josh Levine to unpack the murder case with no clear answer. They reveal the twists that changed their view of the case, the amateur sleuths who gave up everything to prove Dana Chandler’s innocence, the alternative suspect, and the shocking decision that changed the third trial. Plus, why they wouldn’t have convicted Chandler and why, after six years investigating, they’re still not sure who killed Mike and Karen. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

The lone holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy triple murder trial has identified himself and is defending his decision. 48-year-old Michael P. Desronvil spoke through his attorney, saying he never had any doubts. Desronvil says he is a devout Catholic and President Trump supporter who understood the law, and believed the evidence and witness testimony pointed to Clancy’s guilt. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

An illegal parking violation in Philadelphia has led to a house of horrors, as investigators recover more than a million digital images of dozens of women. Although no bodies have been found at the home of 44-year-old Eugene Horsch that was previously shared with his late, pornographic filmmaker father Raymond, some of those images depict “lifeless” women and in one case shows what appears to be a woman being strangled. Among the mountain of evidence removed from the house, 5 urns with remains inside and dozens of barrels in the basement containing an unknown liquid. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

49-year-old Jeffery Lee is set to become Alabama’s second execution of the year at 6 pm ET. Lee was scheduled to die back in June via nitrogen gas for the double murder of a pawn shop owner and his employee. Lee also shot and thought he killed a second employee who played dead, but was able to call 9-1-1 and identify Lee. Lee was only sentenced to death after a judge overruled a jury of his peers who voted 7 to 5 for life in prison. A 2017 law in Alabama no longer allows judges to overrule a jury’s ruling, but it’s not retroactive, and does nothing to spare Lee from dying by lethal injection this evening. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

After years of horrific abuse, Rickie Kananen admitted killing both his parents. Then he accused his sister Stacey of being responsible for the murders. Brendan Taylor joins Elisa to reveal the real Rickie behind "Monster in the Family" and the chillingly “normal” man he saw while watching the actual court footage. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.