All the Queen’s Men: Elizabeth I and Courtship as Foreign Policy With Historian Sophie Shorland

OCT 30, 202639 MIN

Description

Historian Sophie Shorland returns to the podcast — last time for The Lost Queen, her book on Catherine of Braganza, the forgotten queen who helped bring tea to Britain. This time she has turned her attention to the most famous queen England ever had, and found a story most of us think we already know but really don't. All the Queen's Men takes the endless question that hung over Elizabeth's entire reign — who will marry the Virgin Queen? — and reframes it completely. Not as a love life, but as foreign policy. Courtship as diplomacy; flirtation as statecraft; a single woman keeping every prince in Europe dangling for decades in order to keep her country alive. Sophie's argument is that the domestic picture of Elizabeth — progresses, tilts, flirting with favorites, and the occasional baffling decision that older scholarship put down to the menopause — makes far more sense once you add the geopolitics back in. When she abruptly invites a French suitor over, it's because the relationship with Spain is deteriorating and she would rather not be invaded. Historians usually reach for a chess metaphor; Sophie prefers poker, because in chess you have one opponent, and Elizabeth was playing against every head of state in Europe and sometimes her own subjects too. Along the way: the ambassadorial brawl over whose heraldic heart had the better arrows; why whoever married Elizabeth would effectively have won England, its navy and its wealth without a shot fired; the Earl of Arundel who spent a fortune in bribes while the queen laughed behind her sleeve; Eric of Sweden signing himself "your most loving Eric" and complaining that four years of courtship felt like ten; Ivan the Terrible, already on roughly his seventh wife, cancelling the Anglo-Russian trade relationship in a huff; and the Duke of Alençon — nicknamed her Frog, possibly for his small froggy fingers — with whom Elizabeth exchanged rings in front of witnesses, which under Tudor law meant they were technically married, before paying him a great deal of money to leave the country. Links Sophie Shorland's Books All the Queen's Men: Power, Ambition, and the Making of Elizabeth I — the US edition, published by Pegasus Books on 27 October 2026 All the Queen's Men at Pegasus Books / Simon & Schuster All the Queen's Men: The Competition to Marry Elizabeth I — the UK edition, which carries a different subtitle The Lost Queen: The Surprising Life of Catherine of Braganza — her previous book, and the subject of her first appearance on this podcast The Lost Queen at Pegasus Books Sophie Shorland at Simon & Schuster Anglotopia Friends of Anglotopia Club Anglotopia Store Takeaways The gap Sophie found wasn't in the research but in the framing. There is superb scholarship on Elizabeth, but it tends to concentrate on the domestic reign — the progresses, the tilts, the flirtations — and some of her decisions look random or even irrational in that frame. One older strand of scholarship attributed a sudden invitation to a French suitor to the menopause. Add the international context and it resolves instantly: her relationship with Spain was deteriorating and she did not want to be invaded by a great power. Her most reliable move was to open a marriage negotiation whenever something went wrong. In 1563 Margaret of Parma, governing the Netherlands, lost patience with English piracy and declared a trade embargo — disastrous for English wool, the country's main export. Elizabeth immediately began courting Margaret's cousin, the Habsburg Archduke Charles of Austria. On its own the courtship looks capricious; with the embargo in view it is obviously repair work. Her accession set off something close to a feeding frenzy. Fights broke out in the corridors outside her rooms; courtiers complained of stumbling over ambassadors and envoys. The Danish and Swedish delegations had near-identical emblems — a heart pierced with arrows versus a heart pierced with javelins — and the resulting quarrel became a genuine diplomatic incident requiring the parties to be separated. The stakes were that high because marrying Elizabeth meant acquiring England. As a woman, it was assumed her husband would head both household and realm; whoever married her became King of England, with her relegated to second place, and with direct control of the navy, the merchant fleet and the country's wealth. This was not theoretical — England had just been pulled into a French war on Spain's behalf during Mary's marriage to Philip, losing Calais, despite Parliament's efforts to limit his powers. Poker beats chess as a metaphor, and Sophie makes the case cheerfully rather than dogmatically. In chess you face one opponent; Elizabeth faced every head of state in Europe and occasionally her own subjects. She played her cards close, to the lasting frustration of even her closest advisors, and she bluffed — especially early on, when the assumption was that an unmarried queen of a militarily humiliated country would be invaded within the year unless she married a great power quickly. The serious contenders were the ones we still remember, plus some we don't. Robert Dudley; the French candidates including Alençon; Archduke Charles; and Frederick, Crown Prince of Denmark, who made real strategic sense — both Protestant, geographically close, and a combined Anglo-Danish grip on the shipping lanes would have been formidable. The long shots are better company. The Earl of Arundel, fabulously rich, spent thousands bribing his way closer to a queen who laughed at him behind her sleeve. Ivan the Terrible, whom most people don't realize was Elizabeth's contemporary, was on roughly his seventh wife. Eric of Sweden wrote for years as "your most loving Eric," complaining that four years of courtship felt like ten — his language so overheated that when the King of Denmark intercepted the letters he was simply baffled. And Adolf of Denmark was briefly a strong contender mainly because he was handsome, which was apparently reason enough to float several candidates. The Alençon courtship went further than any other and nearly became real. He was nineteen to her thirty-seven when it began, the youngest of four brothers and correspondingly ambitious, and one of the very few foreign suitors to actually make the trip. By his second visit she was forty-five — her last realistic chance to use the tactic. She promised to marry him before witnesses, he said the same, and they exchanged rings, which under Tudor practice meant they were married: no church service, no signature, just the words before witnesses. Ladies fainted. The Spanish ambassador reported home that this time she was serious. Spain relented, Elizabeth got what she wanted — and then had to extract herself, paying Alençon handsomely to leave and go fight his war in the Netherlands, with Dudley sent to make sure he actually went. Jean de Simier, Alençon's envoy, is the episode's great comic discovery. Sent to England partly because he'd just fled France after a duel over his brother's affair with his wife, he flirted outrageously with Elizabeth on his master's behalf, stole her nightcap from her bedchamber to send back to Alençon, was rumored to be having an affair with her, survived assassination attempts, switched to working for Elizabeth after quarrelling with another Frenchman — and when Cecil discovered he had been taking enormous Spanish bribes throughout, Elizabeth was so fond of him that she simply let it go. Elizabeth said she would never marry when she was eight, and said it again in her first address to Parliament, declaring she would remain a vestal virgin married to England. With hindsight, Sophie notes, it is baffling that everyone assumed otherwise. The closest we have to her strategy in writing is Walsingham's exasperation from Paris — essentially, I know what you're doing, and stringing the French along will not get you an alliance, it will just make them angry. Soundbites "It suddenly makes sense why she was inviting a suitor over from France. It's because her relationship with Spain was deteriorating and she wanted, basically, to not be invaded by a great power." "Fights were breaking out outside her rooms, in the corridors. The Danes used a heart pierced with arrows, and the Swedes used a heart pierced with javelins — and this was a diplomatic contretemps. There was a big fight. They had to be separated." "Here is an opportunity to basically conquer England, a pretty wealthy country, without any bloodshed." — Sophie on why Europe lost its head over Elizabeth's accession. "Chess, you only have one opponent — whereas Elizabeth was playing against every head of state, basically, in Europe, and sometimes also her own subjects." "He spent thousands and thousands of pounds bribing people trying to get close to her, and she just kind of laughed at him behind her sleeve." — on the Earl of Arundel. "He'd only been courting her for four years, but it felt like ten." — Eric of Sweden, whose letters were so florid that the King of Denmark intercepted them and couldn't work out what was going on. "She nicknamed him her frog, possibly because he had very small little fingers, like little froggy hands — which is slightly odd to think about." "For Tudors it technically meant that they were married. You didn't need a church service, you didn't need to sign anything. All you needed to do was say I will marry you, I will marry you, in front of witnesses, and you're done." "At one point the Spanish ambassador is just casually saying: maybe I'll assassinate this Italian spy. No — but actually, people might notice, so probably won't bother. I'll just intercept his letters." "Once you've played the card of a marriage, you can't play that card again. Whereas if you just keep promising, you get almost the same benefits — and then you can reuse the same card." Chapters 00:21 Welcome — A Guest Our Listeners Have Met Before 00:29 Sophie Shorland and The Lost Queen — Catherine of Braganza 00:40 THE NEW BOOK — All the Queen's Men 00:58 The Question That Hung Over the Entire Reign 01:03 Reframed: Not a Love Life, but Foreign Policy 01:22 From the Forgotten Queen to the Most Famous One 01:36 "Who Doesn't Want to Write a Book About Elizabeth?" 01:56 Was Her Reputation Deserved — Or Was She Just Lucky? 02:23 WHAT WAS MISSING FROM THE LITERATURE 02:41 The Focus on the Domestic Reign 02:57 Progresses, Tilts, and Apparently Random Decisions 03:04 The Menopause Theory 03:14 Add the Geopolitics and It Makes Sense 03:29 Not Wanting to Be Invaded by a Great Power 03:45 COURTSHIP AS FOREIGN POLICY 03:56 What Changes When You See It That Way 04:04 "A Bit of a Capricious Flirt" — The Old Characterization 04:19 The Strategy She Used Well Into Her Forties 04:35 1563 — MARGARET OF PARMA'S TRADE EMBARGO 04:49 Disastrous for English Wool 04:58 So She Courts the Habsburg Archduke Charles 05:18 Not Prescience, but Pattern 05:34 "TWENTY SEASONS OF THE BACHELOR AT ONCE" 05:48 Fights in the Corridors 06:07 Arrows vs. Javelins — A Diplomatic Contretemps 06:20 Why It Was Such a Huge Deal in Europe 06:37 Conquering England Without Bloodshed 06:44 Stumbling Over Ambassadors and Envoys 07:00 ENGLAND AS A EUROPEAN SWING STATE 07:10 Why Marrying Her Meant Winning England 07:17 Her Husband Would Head the Realm 07:32 The Navy, the Merchant Fleet, the Wealth 07:44 The Precedent — Mary, Philip, and the Loss of Calais 08:06 Parliament Tried to Limit His Powers and Couldn't 08:11 CHESS OR POKER? 08:23 One Opponent vs. Every Head of State in Europe 08:42 Cards Close to the Chest, Even From Her Advisors 08:59 A Big Fan of the Bluff 09:08 A Difficult Hand, Early in the Reign 09:18 The Assumption She'd Be Invaded Unless She Married Fast 09:27 THE FIELD OF SUITORS 09:44 The Serious Contenders 09:59 Frederick of Denmark, and Control of the Shipping Lanes 10:22 THE LONG SHOTS ARE MORE ENTERTAINING 10:31 The Earl of Arundel, Bribing His Way Nowhere 10:48 Ivan the Terrible, Eric the Mad, Adolf of Denmark 11:14 Candidates Floated Purely for Being Handsome 11:28 Ivan's Seventh Wife, and a Poor Track Record 11:47 HOW REAL WERE THEY? 12:08 Elements of Theatre in All the Courtships 12:31 Ivan's Competitiveness With Eric and Sweden 12:40 "Your Most Loving Eric" 12:56 Letters Intercepted by a Baffled King of Denmark 13:16 Ivan's Fury, and the Anglo-Russian Trade Rupture 13:47 Did Elizabeth Ever Enter Them in Good Faith? 14:02 FROG — The Duke of Alençon 14:12 Nineteen to Her Thirty-Seven 14:31 One of the Few Suitors to Actually Come to England 14:38 Convenient Timing — Spain Deteriorating Over Piracy 14:55 A Very Theatrical Flirtation 14:59 Little Froggy Hands 15:12 Lying Around All Morning in His Crimson Bed 15:28 By the Second Visit She Was Forty-Five 15:41 Her Last Chance to Use the Strategy 15:47 A Spanish Ambassador Who Had Seen It All Before 15:51 THE RINGS EXCHANGED BEFORE WITNESSES 15:59 Which, for Tudors, Meant They Were Married 16:13 Ladies Fainting; Spain Relenting 16:31 Awkwardly Disentangling Herself 16:39 Paying Him to Leave and Fight in the Netherlands 16:45 Dudley Sent to Make Sure He Went 16:54 Catherine de' Medici Furious With Her Son 17:10 Twenty-Three, Half Her Age, and Outclassed at Statecraft 17:25 JEAN DE SIMIER — The Ape 17:46 Flirting on His Master's Behalf 18:08 Why He Needed to Leave France in a Hurry 18:30 Stealing Her Nightcap to Send Back to Alençon 18:42 Rumors of an Affair 18:51 Quarrels, Defection, and Spanish Bribes 19:03 Elizabeth Was So Fond of Him She Let It Go 19:06 ROBERT DUDLEY 19:17 Playing the Role a King Would Have Played 19:33 Greeting the King of Sweden's Brother — And the Awkward Climb Down 19:55 Pushing for a Spanish Alliance, and Religious Concessions 20:11 An English Suitor Positioning Himself as a Foreign Prince 20:22 Offered to Mary Queen of Scots 20:35 1578 — DUDLEY MARRIES LETTICE KNOLLYS 20:43 Elizabeth Boxes Her Ears 20:47 "But One Sun Lights the East" 20:53 Her Father's Temper, and Real Jealousy 21:05 Dudley's Difficult Position — He Wanted an Heir 21:13 The Spooky Resemblance 21:26 Marrying the Queen's Doppelgänger, Who Is Also Her Cousin 22:00 THE TACTICS, STEP BY STEP 22:14 The Ring Exchange as the Peak — By Then Nobody Believed Her 22:24 Charming Whichever Ambassador She Wanted to Encourage 22:33 Baron Helfenstein, Boat Trips and Laughing at His Jokes 22:45 Asking for Portraits, and Descriptions of How Attractive He Was 23:02 THE MARRIAGE TREATIES 23:17 The Fleshed-Out Alençon Treaty 23:23 One Son Would Rule England and France 23:30 Two Sons, and the Crowns Split 23:42 Letting Them Be Drawn Up to Signal Seriousness 23:53 Then Invoking Religion to Withdraw 24:14 WHAT SINGLENESS BOUGHT ENGLAND 24:20 Permanent Flexibility; Always Available for an Alliance 24:30 Henry VIII Used the Same Trick With His Daughters 24:42 Mary Cottoned On and Lamented She'd Die a Maid 24:53 "Once You've Played the Card, You Can't Play It Again" 25:07 HER BODY AS DIPLOMATIC INTELLIGENCE 25:25 Always Being Looked At, Even as a Delegitimised Princess 25:42 The Spanish Ambassador Bribing Her Ladies to Inspect Her Sheets 25:49 How Openly People Discussed the Monarch's Body 26:04 Royal Autopsies and the Stories That Followed 26:23 Using It to Her Advantage 26:33 Called an Old Woman, She Danced Vigorously for the Ambassadors 26:53 DID SHE EVER DECIDE OUTRIGHT? 27:06 "I Will Never Marry" — Aged Eight 27:12 A Vestal Virgin, Married to England 27:26 Baffling, in Hindsight, That Anyone Assumed Otherwise 27:41 Walsingham's Exasperation From Paris 28:08 THE SPANISH ARMADA 28:28 It Came After Marriage Was Biologically Off the Table 28:47 Would She Have Opened Negotiations if She'd Been Twenty Years Younger? 29:00 A Secure French Alliance, and Mary Queen of Scots Beheaded 29:30 Confident Enough to Keep Antagonizing Spain 29:33 The English National Pastime 29:48 THE ARCHIVES 30:02 Catty, Casual Ambassadorial Reports 30:23 "Maybe I'll Assassinate This Italian Spy" 30:47 Cecil Running Rings Around a Naive Spanish Ambassador 31:10 THE SECRET WORLD 31:23 Letters, Codes and Messengers Waiting Outside the Door 31:38 Ambassadors Courting the Queen by Proxy 31:52 "I'm Sending You a Budget for Some Bribery" 32:03 Bribery as Entirely Normal 32:13 A Court Where Secrets Were Nearly Impossible 32:28 Gossip Written Down Just in Case 32:46 Did She Prefer the Ambassadors to Their Masters? 32:58 De Feria, and a Queen Who Respected a Good Plotter 33:17 BEYOND THE CATE BLANCHETT ELIZABETH 33:39 What the Films Get Right — Authority, and Commanding Men 33:57 THE MAKEUP MYTH 34:06 The Lead and the Rouge Almost Certainly Never Happened 34:13 Invented by a Jesuit Who Never Saw Her 34:21 Contemporaries Described a Very Fair Face 34:29 WHERE TO GO IN ELIZABETH'S FOOTSTEPS 34:50 Hatfield House — Where She Learned She Was Queen 35:00 Hever Castle — Anne Boleyn, and Anne of Cleves 35:15 Queen Elizabeth's Hunting Lodge, Epping Forest 35:49 The National Portrait Gallery and the Coronation Portrait 36:10 A Future Elizabethan Travel Episode? 36:17 RESCUING QUEENS FROM THE MARGINS 36:30 Diplomacy and Geopolitics as the Connecting Thread 36:50 Elizabeth Was Educated to Be a Diplomat 37:10 WHAT'S NEXT 37:27 The Duke of Anjou Elected King of Poland 37:34 And the Court Dwarf Who Brokered It 37:59 Wrap-Up Video Version