Between Myth and Belief

PeaPod Productions

Trick or Terror: Three Halloween Urban Legends and Creepypasta

OCT 31, 202662 MIN

Description

Grab a hot cuppa, a blanket, and dim the lights. This All Hallows’ Eve, Between Myth and Belief is telling three modern urban legends and creepypasta tales about murder, memory, and blame, and we’re asking why stories like these refuse to stay buried. First, the Candy Lady of Terrell, Texas. In 1903, children begin finding candy and handwritten notes on their bedroom windowsills, and suspicion lands on Clara Crane, a real woman who was convicted of poisoning her husband and then vanished from the records. Next, Candle Cove, the legendary creepypasta about a strange local kids’ show that a handful of forum users swear they remember. Finally, a Halloween night in 1962, a house full of teenagers in homemade masks, and a photograph that may be older than the story told about it. Along the way, we talk about how childhood memory plays tricks on us, why creepypasta is basically written improv, the TV shows only we seem to remember, and what it means to believe a story because we want it to be true. Spoiler warning for our own sake: if you already know these tales, please don’t give away the endings. The photo for the last story:  Then stick around for the Calendar of the Weird. Halloween may be over by midnight, but the weirdness has other plans. This fortnight brings late-night ghost hunts, celebrations honoring the dead, community rituals, and an extremely early visit from everyone’s favorite Alpine Christmas menace. Here are the events mentioned in our Calendar of the Weird: OCTOBER 31: Halloween Ghost Hunt | Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum, Weston, West Virginia. Overnight paranormal investigation, 11:30 p.m. to 6 a.m. https://trans-alleghenylunaticasylum.com/schedule-of-events/ OCTOBER 31 to NOVEMBER 1: Día de Muertos | Mano a Mano, St. Mark’s Church-in-the-Bowery, New York City. Free community altar, traditional art, performances, and remembrance. https://www.manoamano.nyc/day-of-the-dead-dia-de-muertos-nyc NOVEMBER 7: Night at the Glore Museum | American Hauntings, St. Joseph, Missouri. Limited-capacity after-hours paranormal investigation. https://www.bumpinthenight.net/ NOVEMBER 7: Día de los Muertos and Diwali Festival | Presidio Tunnel Tops, San Francisco, California. Free celebration featuring storytelling, cultural activities, and a fire ceremony. https://presidio.gov/explore/events/dia-de-los-muertos-and-diwali-festival NOVEMBER 8: 37th Annual All Souls Procession | Tucson, Arizona. A community procession and remembrance ceremony. Gathering at 4 p.m., procession at 6 p.m. https://allsoulsprocession.org/all-souls-procession-guidelines/ NOVEMBER 13 to 14: Paranormal Tour and Overnight Ghost Hunt | Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum, Weston, West Virginia. Friday tour 9:30 to 11:30 p.m.; Saturday ghost hunt 9 p.m. to 5 a.m. https://trans-alleghenylunaticasylum.com/schedule-of-events/ NOVEMBER 14: Krampus Holiday Market | Morbid Anatomy, Tom Kane Theater, Industry City, Brooklyn, New York. Oddities, gothic art, taxidermy, and Krampus-themed shopping, 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. https://www.morbidanatomy.org/events-tickets/p/krampus-market-2026-zacs2 Have a tale to tell? Email us at [email protected] or find us on Instagram and Bluesky at @mythandbelief. Follow and subscribe wherever you listen, and visit our other podcast, Cozy Quilt Cinema, at CozyQuiltCinema.com.   Sounds used in episode:  Halloween01.mp3 by Filax -- https://freesound.org/s/169319/ -- License: Creative Commons 0