FIR Podcast Network

FIR Podcast Network

FIR #535: Communicating in the Wake of Big Tech’s Big Political Gamble

NOV 12, 202627 MIN

Description

Political access can open doors, but what happens when the political landscape changes? Big Tech’s close relationships with Donald Trump set the stage for a discussion of corporate reputation, executive judgment, and the limits of communications counsel. Nick Clegg’s assessment of Silicon Valley’s embrace of Trump raises a familiar question: Does having a seat at the executive table mean communicators have the influence to challenge a potentially damaging decision? Neville Hobson and Shel Holtz explore what chief communication officers should advise when commercial interests, political relationships, and corporate values collide, and what to do when that advice is ignored. They also consider how to prepare executives for scrutiny, answer employees’ questions, and rebuild trust through changes in behavior. For communicators, the challenge extends well beyond explaining a CEO’s decisions to helping shape better ones. Links from this episode: When political access becomes a reputational liability Tech Billionaires Face Tricky Political Waters After Democratic Midterm Sweep Getting Too Close to Trump Was a Mistake Silicon Valley’s political spending spree meets a blue wave — and a data center revolt Corporations Pour Record-Smashing $737 Million Into 2026 Midterms Preparing for Congressional Oversight in the 120th Congress: What Organizations Should Expect Prepare Now for Congressional Oversight Investigations Industry still has room to close the AI trust gap Communities opposed to data centers will end up “backwards and poor,” Trump says The next monthly, long-form episode of FIR is tentatively scheduled to drop on Monday, November 30. We host a Communicators Zoom Chat most Thursdays at 1 p.m. ET. To obtain the credentials needed to participate, contact Shel or Neville directly, request them in our Facebook group, or email [email protected]. Special thanks to Jay Moonah for the opening and closing music. You can find the stories from which Shel’s FIR content is selected at Shel’s Link Blog. You can catch up with both co-hosts on Neville’s blog and Shel’s blog. Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this podcast are Shel’s and Neville’s and do not reflect the views of their employers and/or clients. Raw Transcript: Shel Holtz: Hi, everybody, and welcome to episode 535 of For Immediate Release. I’m Shel Holtz. Neville Hobson: And I’m Neville Hobson. The Democrats’ sweeping victories in the U.S. midterm elections have changed the political landscape dramatically, and some of America’s biggest technology companies may now be wondering whether their close relationships with Donald Trump have become a reputational liability. Over the past two years, big tech executives have invested considerable money and effort in cultivating those relationships. Some went well beyond conventional political engagement, with public displays of loyalty that sometimes looked remarkably like appeasement. Elon Musk is perhaps the most extreme example. According to Politico, he spent around $446 million supporting candidates in the midterms, many, if not most, of whom lost. Now, with Democrats set to control both houses of Congress, there’s talk of investigations into corporate relationships with the Trump administration, including possible preferential treatment and commercial arrangements. There’s an interesting perspective on all this from Nick Clegg, the former U.K. deputy prime minister and former president of global affairs at Meta. Writing in The Atlantic this week, Clegg argues that Silicon Valley’s embrace of Trump was a predictable strategic miscalculation driven by competitive fear of missing out, political grievances, and overconfidence. What particularly caught my attention was his suggestion that a kind of herd mentality took hold. Once Musk established his relationship with Trump, other technology executives apparently feared being left behind. That’s a fascinating challenge for senior communicators. If a CEO believes competitors are gaining political advantages, how does a chief communication officer persuade that CEO to consider the longer-term reputational risks? If everyone else appears to be making the same calculation, does that make it harder to challenge the prevailing wisdom? Of course, companies need constructive relationships with governments. But there’s a significant difference between political engagement and becoming so closely identified with a particular leader that your company’s reputation becomes tied to their political fortunes. I explored this in an article on my Studio6 blog earlier this week. What particularly interests me, Shel, is the role of senior corporate communicators in these decisions. We discussed this ourselves in FIR 532 a few weeks ago, when we questioned whether having a seat at the executive table actually translates into genuine influence. These political relationships present a particularly revealing test. Were communication leaders involved when their CEOs decided to cultivate such close relationships with Trump? Did they challenge the decisions? We simply don’t know. They may have given excellent advice and been overruled, or they may have had little involvement in the decisions at all. But there’s an important distinction here. It’s one thing for a CEO not to recognize the reputational risks of a particular course of action. It’s quite another to understand those risks and decide that the commercial benefits justify taking them anyway. If the CEO knowingly proceeds, has the communicator fulfilled their responsibility by explaining the risks and making a recommendation? Or should they do more, perhaps ensuring the implications are considered by the wider leadership team or board? Remember, these are global companies. What looks like pragmatic political engagement in Washington may look quite different to employees, investors, and customers in London, Brussels, or elsewhere. I have two questions. First, looking back over the past two years, what should the CCOs of these technology companies have been advising their CEOs? If Clegg is right about the herd mentality in Silicon Valley, how would communicators have challenged that thinking? What should they have done if their advice was ignored? It’s worth mentioning that Nick Clegg occupied such a role when he was at Meta. What did he do about all this? Facebook was one of the companies involved, with Mark Zuckerberg cozying up to Trump. Second, what should those same CCOs be advising now? Should they defend the political relationships as commercially necessary, acknowledge mistakes where appropriate, or recommend a more fundamental reassessment of how their companies engage with political power? The question isn’t simply how to communicate your way out of a difficult situation. It’s whether communication leaders have the influence, judgment, and courage to help prevent that situation from arriving in the first place. Shel Holtz: It’s been an interesting week here in the U.S., to say the least. I do want to offer our usual disclaimer that we’re not expressing our own personal political views here. We’re talking about the political landscape and its impact on communicators in the wake of the “blue tsunami,” as it’s being referred to. Usually these are waves, but this was a big wave. To your first question—what should these CCOs have been doing over the last two years?—I think they should have been sharing polling numbers and other data with their leaders. They should have been showing them that the numbers were looking pretty bleak in terms of approval ratings for Trump in general and his handling of the economy, but also for data centers and AI. The U.S. has an outsized hatred of AI. If you look at the data center resolutions on the ballot in multiple states and municipalities, I think I heard there was one that passed that actually favored data centers. The other 40-some that passed were moratoriums and other measures to slow or stop the development of these huge buildings. There was plenty for communicators to share with their leaders, saying, “Look, the headwinds are tough, and going all in with Trump is going to backfire on you. It may be time to take your foot off the gas on this particular relationship.” I have no doubt that the reason they didn’t is that they were pretty high on the lack of regulation. What they all want is to pursue the development of their products without being hindered by regulation. I think that’s the main thing they were interested in. The mantra we keep hearing from both the government and industry leaders is that we have to beat China, and anything we do to constrain that effort is going to harm U.S. national security and our leadership in AI. I heard just yesterday—I think I was listening to Machine Gods, the new podcast from Kevin Roose and Casey Newton, who formerly did Hard Fork at The New York Times and are now with NPR—that one of the lowest-polling statements anybody could make to a voter was, “We have to do this to beat China.” I think it was Casey Newton who said that would get you thrown out of the room by the average voter, who doesn’t care about China. They care about these things in their neighborhoods, jacked-up electricity rates, the environment, their jobs, and whether they’ll be alive in five years. I think these leaders got high on the support they were getting for their viewpoint, and that made them want to cozy up to the administration. Here we are. The Democrats could read the tea leaves. They made tech titans—and this is a quote, although I don’t remember who said it—“avatars of inequality and corruption.” This was in their victory speeches. The Nasdaq dropped more than 5% on AI stock selling, and executives are now facing any number of investigations in Congress. Then there was Reid Hoffman, who is on the left but is a tech billionaire, who said that MAGA Valley voices are the “misleaders of the Valley.” Apparently, that got a lot of attention. We can talk about that before moving on to what these communication officers should be doing now. Neville Hobson: Maybe we should. An observation, thinking about what you said: I remember seeing it, and The Atlantic’s piece by Nick Clegg has the photograph as its hero image, of these tech leaders in profile. It starts with Zuckerberg, then Lauren Sánchez, Jeff Bezos, the guy from Google whose name I can never remember, and Elon Musk. They’re all lined up. It made me think they were jostling for position. I remember seeing it on TV and thinking, “What do they think they’re doing, for God’s sake?” They’re cozying up to Trump—not the administration per se. It was actually Trump they were getting close to. Shel Holtz: You saw the pictures of them all at these dinners, in their tuxes, at the head table with him. Neville Hobson: That’s exactly right. This comes back to the central point: What advice did they get on this? Was this a good idea? Or were they so hell-bent on doing it that they brushed aside what anyone else was going to say? That’s what it looks like to me. These are smart people. They’ve built businesses. They lead some of the biggest companies in the world, in the technology industry at that. Yet they did this. They felt it was absolutely the right thing to do to benefit their businesses. Surely they must have overruled advice. I can’t believe for a second that communicators, particularly senior communicators, didn’t give them advice on what to do here. Shel Holtz: You would certainly hope communicators were advising them to do what would be best. Neville Hobson: “Don’t do this.” Shel Holtz: “Do what’s in the long-term interests of the company and your shareholders.” I haven’t read anything from one of these tech company CCOs about what they were doing before or the kind of counsel they were giving. Obviously, they wouldn’t go public with that and make their bosses look bad. We don’t know, but I agree. At least some of these chief communication officers had to be advising their CEOs that this wasn’t going to end well. The writing was on the wall, and has been for a couple of years. One of the things Nick Clegg said in that Atlantic piece that I found interesting relates to your point: These are very smart people. They’ve spun up these companies with valuations approaching a trillion dollars. They’re huge businesses that rake in money and have high margins. It doesn’t mean they’re smart about politics. What Clegg said was that they pretend they are, and they wax poetic on political issues they really don’t understand. That’s why you have government relations people in an organization: to provide counsel on that. But look at the governance in place in some of these organizations. The board cannot get rid of Mark Zuckerberg. It’s structured so they can’t do that. In fact, that was true of Jensen Huang. His share ownership and the like were structured so the board couldn’t fire him. He resigned. This is actually breaking news as we’re recording, probably because he could see the writing on the wall and knew what was coming. Of course, this has nothing to do with his cozying up to Trump, which he did. Although there is a Trump angle here, in that he knew about this relationship with a spy a year ago and really just brushed it off. Just the other day, he said, “Jensen’s still going to come with me on this trip to Asia.” I also saw that the Singapore government was saying the U.S. was no help in trying to deal with this spy, Alice Wong. I hope it’s a wake-up call for these leaders and that they realize they really do need to listen. There’s an opportunity for communicators who may have been brushed aside by some very arrogant CEOs who didn’t see any risk in cozying up to Trump. They need to start paying attention to the people whose jobs involve looking at the impact on corporate reputation and the long-term implications of sullying it. Neville Hobson: You’d hope that’s what they would do. But one of Nick Clegg’s points is this whole business of herd mentality. The way he framed the tech leaders’ cozying up was the simplistic fear of missing out: “I saw what Musk did. I see what these guys do. We’d better get in there because we’re going to miss out otherwise.” Jensen Huang, whom you referenced, is now the ex-CEO of Nvidia. As you said, the announcement is breaking news today. That’s November 11 as we’re recording this. He was the CEO of the second-most highly valued company in the world after Apple, worth over a trillion dollars. The numbers are mind-boggling. Shel Holtz: At one point, they were number one for a while. Neville Hobson: But the hit to their share price and market value—the fall in value—has been equally astonishing. You mentioned when we were talking earlier, and I agree, that it undoubtedly will recover. I think it’s going to take a while, depending on whom they hire as CEO. They’ve got an interim in place for the time being. The herd mentality Clegg mentioned is a valid analysis to try to explain what happened. What it doesn’t address, because we don’t know, is what counsel and advice they received. Did they get any? Did they get it and decide, “No, I’m going to go ahead and do this anyway”? We simply don’t know. Expand this beyond these highly valued tech companies to everyday businesses. I’m not talking about small businesses here. I mean enterprise businesses, big companies, where similar situations would arise. One thing I do believe is that what Trump does, and what he has done, has global effects. Look at what he’s been doing with this stupid war he started in Iran that’s caused economic mayhem everywhere. The role of communicators is in line with what we’ve discussed previously. You’ve got a seat at the table. Have you got the influence? Do you have the understanding of business, global business, financial markets, and your company’s position in the overall ecosystem? If you’re senior and occupy that role, you should, and I’m sure many do. This often comes up in my thinking: the book by my friend Tabita Andersson, who interviewed 23 chief communication officers in a book she published in December last year. Some of what they discuss illustrates very clearly that those individuals have the wisdom, knowledge, and insight into the markets in which their companies operate, and a wider view of what it all means for their businesses. I would imagine those companies recognize the value of communicators. That’s another point regarding the herd of tech companies: Do they not recognize the value of their communicators? Otherwise, they’d be paying attention to them, right? Shel Holtz: I think there’s a certain amount of hubris in play, too. You’re not seeing a lot of humility among these tech leaders. If you look at the CEO of a consumer packaged goods company, a pharmaceutical company, or a traditional industry, they’ve come up through the ranks over time. These companies may be decades old, some even 100 or 120 years old, and they have respect for what communication officers bring to the table. In the tech industry, these are relatively new companies started by founders who are now billionaire CEOs. That has led to a certain arrogance: “I know better than anybody else, because look where I’ve gotten in the space of 10, 15, or 20 years.” How long has Anthropic been around? Not that long, and yet it’s going to have the highest valuation of any IPO in history. I’ve been hearing about what this will mean to employees who had options. There are going to be a lot of millionaires at Anthropic very soon. I think it leads to a certain arrogance: “I know better than my communicators. I’m going to listen to them.” What was the line from the Lerner and Loewe lyrics in My Fair Lady? “I listen very nicely, then go out and do precisely what I want.” That’s kind of what they do. I don’t get the sense, from what I’ve seen so far, that they’re listening to their communicators now. If this is the result of listening, then I question the value of those communicators. This U-turn of renaming data centers “compute campuses”—come on. We’re already seeing advocates for more moderation in the building of data centers calling this “PR washing.” You’re seeing some tech leaders try to shift back to the middle, and some critics are calling that a little too late. There are things communicators can do. One is to prepare leaders to give testimony at congressional hearings. You’ve got to get the receipts, your audit trail, and your records, and have all that ready to go. Congressional hearings aren’t trials. There’s no judge or jury. There are questions under oath, and any documentation you provide can be made public. Communicators can help prepare their leaders to look as good as possible, but also to be honest, somewhat self-effacing, and a little humble in these hearings. Then it’s about moving forward. Like any crisis, what are we going to change to make sure this doesn’t happen again? That’s where the real opportunity lies: for communicators to help guide a strategy for how the company will engage with political leaders at the national level, even when it affects the company’s own desires. In this case, particularly, it’s the desire to avoid regulation. The perception is that regulation will slow them down and China will win. China doesn’t have a lead, but from everything I’ve seen, they’re not catching up as much as they were before. It doesn’t seem so urgent to me that we should ignore what the public is asking for, which is regulation. It’s up to communicators now to ask: What message are we going to send about how we’ll engage with political leaders in the future? Be detailed and strategic. Spend the time sitting down with your government relations people, lawyers, and regulatory people to hammer out a solution that becomes the guidance. Then you need to be able to say, “Look, our leaders are walking the talk.” That’s how you rebuild trust. It’s going to take time, but I think it’s possible. These leaders are genuinely going to have to walk the talk. Neville Hobson: I agree. Related to that, you mentioned congressional inquiries, which won’t affect everyone. But there are some pragmatic things worth thinking about. What should your company say if you’re asked, “Why did you cozy up to Trump?” Shel Holtz: The reporters are going to be calling. This is the short term. Neville Hobson: What are you going to say? You could defend it as a legitimate effort to protect your company’s commercial interests. You could emphasize that engagement with government is a practical necessity, regardless of which party holds power. Both arguments may be entirely reasonable. You could reassert the company’s independence, explaining that its principles and commitments have remained consistent throughout. But caution: that explanation becomes difficult if the evidence suggests otherwise. Or you could acknowledge that certain decisions were politically expedient, perhaps even mistaken, and explain what the organization has learned. That’s a considerably harder conversation with your CEO. On the one hand, you’ve got the big picture of congressional inquiries into your decision-making. On the other, you’ve got journalists and others asking, “Why did you do this?” What are you going to say? You’ve got to think about that. It’s something communicators need to pay attention to. Shel Holtz: One more thought: Your employees are going to be asking about this as well. Internal communicators in these big tech companies need to think about that, too. You’re going to have employees saying, “We have these core values we keep hearing about. They’re on signs on the wall, our security badges, company fleet vehicles—everywhere. Yet this behavior was inconsistent with them. What happened in 2024 that made our leaders abandon these values?” You need to be prepared to give a straight answer, not a brand statement, and equip managers with facts. The other thing is that you can’t promise what you don’t know. You can’t go out there and say, “There’s not going to be any investigation of us,” when you don’t know that. You need to be prepared to answer these questions honestly. Again, what are we going to do going forward to ensure we don’t find ourselves back here the next time we all get overly enthusiastic and follow the herd, only to find ourselves facing falling share values, potential investigations, and definitely some impending regulation? Neville Hobson: That’s a very good point: the publicly stated values and commitments, those things companies talk about when they think it will present them in a good light. What impact does this have on them? Have we changed them? That’s a valid question. If I were an employee, I might be thinking that, perhaps even asking about it. You need to be absolutely clear about where you stand and whether your values have changed. If they have—or if something has contradicted the company’s stated purposes—you’d better be prepared to justify that. It could be difficult. Nevertheless, this suggests you can’t just sit there observing. You need to prepare for what you need to do now in light of these midterm results. Shel Holtz: Absolutely. Listeners, if any of you work for one of these big tech companies, we’d love to hear what’s going on in your organization. And that will be a 30 for this episode of For Immediate Release. The post FIR #535: Communicating in the Wake of Big Tech’s Big Political Gamble appeared first on FIR Podcast Network.