/https://substackcdn.com/feed/podcast/1328800/75b73d4eb7b6a30c2677afec05a11837.jpg)
Five Before Five Podcast
Hamzah Henshaw
The Kind of Opposition Most Muslims Don’t Know How to Handle
APR 4, 20262 MIN
/https://substackcdn.com/feed/podcast/1328800/post/193159954/c30e90ffcec8bcaef23d435e622a388b.jpg)
Description
Most Muslim communities don’t lose because they lack resources.
They lose because they respond to resistance the wrong way.
Not to hard opposition. Hard opposition is actually easier. You know what you’re dealing with.
I’m talking about soft opposition. Polite discomfort. Procedural resistance that sounds reasonable on the surface. “We have concerns about parking.” “The schedule doesn’t allow for it.” “We’d need to review the policy.”
We mishandle it almost every time. We react emotionally and defensively instead of strategically.
I want to tell you a story I heard this morning during a community breakfast. It’s one I didn’t live through myself. But I inherited the result of it, and it changed how I think about many of the challenges our communities face.
Al-Noor Academy, the school where I spent years helping Muslim students get into Harvard and MIT, almost didn’t get its building.
ANA, the first Muslim high school in New England, had been operating out of the basement of a mosque in Quincy since its founding in 2000. Within a few years they’d completely outgrown the space and needed a proper building.
They found one. The old St. Mary’s Church in Mansfield. The oldest church in town. A Catholic parish that had built a newer, bigger church nearby, leaving the original empty and up for sale. About 15,000 square feet. Exactly what they needed.
But here’s what made this location especially attractive.
The church was walking distance from the Mansfield commuter rail station. The Boston-to-Providence line passes right through. This would allow students coming from Boston, from Providence, from all over to get to school on their own. Working parents who didn’t have to drive 45 minutes each way. That train station was the difference between a school that was accessible and one that wasn’t.
So the school expressed interest in purchasing the building.
And then one man stood up.
He said St. Mary’s was where his parents had gotten married. He said he was uncomfortable with it being purchased by Muslims. He wanted to “save” St. Mary’s.
He petitioned. He complained. He made noise.
The typical Muslim response would have been predictable. Get angry. Get self-righteous. Write op-eds. Rally the community and make it a battle about Islamophobia.
But alhamdulillah, our founders had real hikmah.
What they did next is something I’ve almost never seen replicated.
They sat down with their lawyer and came up with a plan.
They went to this man and said: Listen. This location works for us because of two things: the square footage and the walking distance from the train station. We’re not attached to the building itself.
So here’s what we’ll do.
We’ll give you 60 days. If you can find us another location that meets those two requirements, 15,000 square feet and walking distance from a commuter rail station, we will happily withdraw our bid.
If not, we move forward.
On the surface, this looked like compromise.
It wasn’t.
They didn’t argue with him. They didn’t try to convince him. They took an emotional objection and turned it into a practical challenge. They gave him dignity, but also responsibility. And they shifted the entire arena. It was no longer a fight about religion and identity. It was a question: Can you solve this better than we can?
Meanwhile, the man took the emotional route. He went out and formed a 'Save Old St. Mary's' nonprofit and sent flyers to the entire town, trying to rally support against the sale.
The school, on the other hand, did something far quieter and more strategic.
They went to every faith community in Mansfield. Including the new St. Mary’s parish. They explained what they were building. What it would bring to the town. Who they were.
They built relationships. One conversation at a time.
The faith leaders of Mansfield—Christian, Jewish, and others—stepped up. They came out publicly and pledged their support for Al-Noor Academy.
Sixty days passed.
The campaign fizzled. The opposition had isolated itself. The school got the building.
They never heard from that man again.
They didn’t win the argument.
They made the argument irrelevant.
I arrived at Al Noor 6 years later. By then, the building had been transformed from a church into a bona fide school. When they renovated, they added a floor halfway up the old church, turning the upper space into a masjid with soaring ceilings that still carry the architecture of St. Mary's. Five times a day, students and the wider local community pray in a space where the old and the new exist together.
But the students who went on to Harvard, MIT, and beyond, the students whose stories and strategy I helped shape, whose lives changed because someone believed in them? Those students didn't appear in a vacuum
They are downstream of decisions like this one.
Every institution our kids benefit from was built by someone who faced resistance and chose strategy over reaction. The building I walked into every day existed because a group of Muslim leaders chose hikmah over anger twenty years earlier.
That’s institutional wisdom. And we are losing it.
This pattern shows up everywhere.
A student trying to get Jumu’ah accommodated at school. A parent asking the district to recognize Eid absences. A family trying to start an MSA. A community seeking a zoning variance to expand their masjid.
And the instinct is always the same. Argue harder. Push back. Or give up.
All three miss the point.
The goal is not to win the argument. The goal is to redesign the situation so the argument collapses on its own.
Absorb, don’t mirror. Shift from values to constraints. Build relationships while the other side builds campaigns. Let time do the work.
Soft front. Firm back.
If you know the seerah, this might sound familiar. At Hudaybiyyah, the Prophet ﷺ made an agreement that looked like a loss. Within two years, Makkah was opened. Restraint is not weakness. It is the hardest form of strength.
Most people never learn how to do this.
Not because it’s complicated. Because it requires something rare.
Restraint when you feel completely justified in reacting.
We don’t lose because we’re blocked.
We lose because we take the bait.
That building is where I discovered my life's calling. Helping young Muslims find their purpose, build futures that honor their deen and their ambitions, and get into colleges most people told them were out of reach. Five Before College was born inside Old St. Mary's Church, because our founders chose hikmah over hysteria.
If this story resonated, I’d love to hear from you. Hit reply or leave a comment. I’m collecting stories like this one. Moments of institutional hikmah from our communities that need to be preserved before they’re forgotten.
And if you have a Muslim teenager who’s starting to think about college, we’d love to meet them. Click this link and let’s explore how Five Before College can help them find their qibla, get into a school they love, and hold on to their identity in the process.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit hamzahhenshaw.substack.com

