/https://img.transistorcdn.com/pq-xjs_ERB6E-puusatwJxe5rHen5KdjmdVbu7rZ5hk/rs:fill:0:0:1/w:1400/h:1400/q:60/mb:500000/aHR0cHM6Ly9pbWct/dXBsb2FkLXByb2R1/Y3Rpb24udHJhbnNp/c3Rvci5mbS81Yzc3/MTM3MzQ3ODczMzQ1/NDZjM2Q0MGQ3Mjc1/YWJiZC5wbmc.jpg)
Good Morning, HR
Mike Coffey, SPHR, SHRM-SCP
Are New Hire Probationary Periods Still a Thing? with John Hagan
NOV 12, 202634 MIN
/https://img.transistorcdn.com/TOxrfvujipXc3PyvzqG9R1bTF2bW0aefw05bNh0TXXs/rs:fill:0:0:1/w:1400/h:1400/q:60/mb:500000/aHR0cHM6Ly9pbWct/dXBsb2FkLXByb2R1/Y3Rpb24udHJhbnNp/c3Rvci5mbS9hZmFh/NzViM2Q1ZGY0MzFj/Mjc0NTdhNzM1Y2Y2/ODU2OC5qcGc.jpg)
Description
In episode 278, Coffey talks with employment attorney John Hagan about a court decision concerning hire probationary periods and how employers should approach new hire training and orientation periods.
They discuss the Fifth Circuit’s Brenyah decision involving a hospital nurse whose 90-day probationary period was extended over performance concerns; how Hamilton v. Dallas County and Muldrow v. City of St. Louis replaced the ultimate employment decision rule with a lower some-harm standard; why lost seniority and termination without cause made the probation extension an adverse employment action; how thorough performance documentation helped the hospital defeat the discrimination and retaliation claims; why renaming probationary periods as orientation periods protects at-will employment status; removing penalties such as delayed seniority or benefits from orientation periods; moving from 90-day to 180-day orientation periods for all new hires to avoid individual extensions; why judges, juries, and plaintiff’s attorneys rarely favor employees fired during an orientation period; the same actor doctrine and its strong inference against discrimination when the same manager hires and fires; communicating at-will status and orientation expectations in the employee handbook and during onboarding; the workplace investigation failures that sent the hostile work environment claim to a jury, including missing notes, contradictory manager accounts, uninterviewed witnesses, and unsigned witness statements; and two quick audits employers can run on their orientation policies and harassment investigation files.
For HR teams who discuss this podcast in their team meetings, we’ve created a discussion starter PDF to help guide your conversation. Download it here https://goodmorninghr.com/EP278
Good Morning, HR is brought to you by Imperative—Bulletproof Background Checks. For more information about our commitment to quality and excellent customer service, visit us at https://imperativeinfo.com.
If you are an HRCI or SHRM-certified professional, this episode of Good Morning, HR has been pre-approved for half a recertification credit. To obtain the recertification information for this episode, visit https://goodmorninghr.com.
About our Guest:
John P. Hagan is an HR attorney who practices nationwide employment law from his office in Allen, Texas and is Board Certified in Texas Labor and Employment Law. He is ranked by his peers to be in the top 5% of all lawyers in Texas and is an award-winning author for the College of the State Bar. Mr. Hagan has written on many employment law issues, including damages, discrimination, and wrongful termination. Mr. Hagan has co-authored the Employment Law Handbook - Texas (Texas Association of Business and Chambers of Commerce) and Texas Employment Law for James Publishing.
Mr. Hagan and his firm represent a wide range of companies of all sizes and in all industries. His specialty is counselling companies using best practices and preventative HR resulting in less litigation.
He has served as President for both DallasHR and Mid-Cities HRA. He served on committees for Collin County HR Association.
Mr. Hagan has been named consistently as a Texas SuperLawyer (©Thomson Reuters) for sixteen years, from 2010 – 2026.
John can be reached at https://www.linkedin.com/in/john-hagan-a3b4064
About Mike Coffey:
Mike Coffey is an entrepreneur, licensed private investigator, HR consultant, and registered yoga teacher.
In 1999, he founded Imperative, a background investigations and due diligence firm helping risk-averse clients make better people decisions.
Imperative delivers in-depth employment background investigations, know-your-customer and anti-money laundering compliance, and due diligence investigations to more than 300 risk-averse corporate clients across the US, and, through its PFC Caregiver & Household Screening brand, hundreds more private estates, family offices, and personal service agencies.
Imperative has been named a Best Places to Work, the Texas Association of Business’ small business of the year, and is accredited by the Professional Background Screening Association.
Mike serves as a board member of a number of organizations, including the Texas State Council, where he serves Texas’ 30 SHRM chapters as State Director-Elect; Workforce Solutions for Tarrant County; the Texas Association of Business; and the Fort Worth Chamber of Commerce, where he is chair of the Talent Committee.
Mike is a certified Senior Professional in Human Resources (SPHR) through the HR Certification Institute and a SHRM Senior Certified Professional (SHRM-SCP). He is also a Yoga Alliance registered yoga teacher (RYT-200) and teaches multiple times each week.
Mike and his very patient wife of 29 years are empty nesters in Fort Worth.
Learning Objectives:
1. Explain how recent federal decisions lowered the threshold for what counts as an adverse employment action in discrimination claims.
2. Evaluate orientation and probationary period policies for consequences, such as lost seniority or delayed benefits, that could make an extension legally risky.
3. Design an orientation period policy and onboarding message that preserve at-will employment status.
4. Assess workplace investigation files for missing witnesses, notes, and follow-up that could expose the employer in a hostile work environment claim.

