I Believe

Joel K. Douglas

Details

Philosophy from the American Experiment joelkdouglas.substack.com

Recent Episodes

NOV 17, 2026
The Ham and English Pea Circuit | The Interstate Compact vs The People
If you wanted to be governor of Georgia in 1958, it helped if you liked ham. Ernest Vandiver ate enough of it to give that part of his political education a name. His wife, Betty, remembered him calling it the “ham and English pea circuit.” You made a speech. Somebody fed you ham and peas. The next town wanted a speech, too. You could probably guess what was for dinner. When Ernie ran for governor, Betty’s mother came to stay with the children. As Betty put it, “Mama moved in and I moved out.” She and Ernie flew to Dublin, Georgia, for his opening rally on July 12. Betty had never seen a rally that big. Between the county seats, they stopped in the little towns. An hour and a half, maybe two hours, and you could walk into every store in town, hand somebody a campaign folder, introduce yourself, and tell them what you were doing there. Why spend two hours in a town small enough that you could introduce yourself to every shopkeeper? Well, Ernie wanted to be governor. And Georgia counted counties. Win Fulton County, home to Atlanta, and you got six units toward the Democratic nomination. Win Echols, Glascock, and Quitman, the three smallest counties in Georgia, and you got six units, too. The 1960 census counted more than half a million people in Fulton. Those other three had fewer than seven thousand people put together. You can see why Ernie got out of the car. You could tell where a candidate needed support by listening to which roads he promised to fix. Under the county system, men running for governor promised rural roads and bridges. They had a good deal less to say about traffic in Atlanta. Come election time, a county could deliver its two units. Come road-building time, the state highway board could reward that county with a contract or make it wait. Vandiver remembered people joking that you knew when you’d crossed the Georgia line because the ride got bumpy. He figured his predecessors had put so much into rural roads that some of the main highways had suffered. You can see why somebody in Atlanta wanted the rules changed. Georgia’s system diluted the political power of Black voters and helped sustain segregation. Vandiver himself campaigned to keep the schools segregated. He won in a landslide in 1958, the last governor Georgia elected under the county-unit system. Four years later, while he was still governor, a federal court blocked the system. The next time Georgians chose a Democratic nominee for governor, the candidate who got the most votes statewide won. In 1972, Ernie wanted to go to Washington as a United States senator. This time the Vandivers had a campaign van. Their children were old enough to help, and Betty remembered the young people working out of headquarters in Atlanta while she and Ernie were on the road. Campaigns used television a good deal more by then. Still, the Vandivers set out to visit every county in Georgia. Betty said they made it. Which brings us back to Echols County. A woman was voting absentee at the courthouse. She was friendly to Ernie and Betty, and as long as she had the ballot in her hands, Betty had every reason to think the visit was going pretty well. Then the woman folded it. Betty caught a glimpse. Vandiver was down at the bottom of the ballot. The woman had put her mark up near the top. She’d voted for Sam Nunn. She owed Ernie Vandiver nothing, and by Betty’s account, that’s about how many votes she gave him. Good for her. Ernie lost. He finished third in the Democratic primary and missed the runoff. That was his last race. Years later, looking back on the two ways he’d run for office, he remembered how much time candidates used to spend in rural Georgia. He also knew where a man who wanted to win now had to go. In his words, “if you want to get elected, you’ve got to spend your time and your money and your efforts in the metropolitan areas.” And what happened to the roads? In the years that followed, Georgia gradually put more state money into urban roads and bridges and gave more support to public transit. If you rode the bus to work, you had good reason to want the governor to hear from you. So did the farmer whose truck had to cross a county bridge. After the speeches and the dinners and the election, somebody still had to decide which road to fix first. Today, the people of Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Arizona, and Nevada face a choice about how Americans elect a president. Last week, voters in all five states gave Democrats the governorship and majorities in both houses of the legislature. Between them, those five states have enough electoral votes to put the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact into effect. The Compact going into effect would essentially nullify the Electoral College. Now, on paper we should be for everybody’s vote counting. One person, one vote. Someone who raises beef cattle in Wisconsin shouldn’t get more say in choosing a president than someone who rides the bus to work in Milwaukee. But we also want a president who can serve the interests of the entire nation. One of our national goals is justice. If we don’t listen to the entire country, how can we set conditions so kids who grow up in projects and trailers everywhere can work to achieve prosperity? And some of the things the entire nation depends on happen in places where very few people live. What reason will a candidate have to go there and hear what those people have to say? Here’s what those five states could join. Each state that joins the compact agrees to give all its electoral votes to the presidential ticket that gets the most votes across the country. The agreement takes effect when the states that join hold enough electoral votes to elect a president. Today that takes 270. Eighteen states and the District of Columbia have joined. Together they have 222. Pennsylvania and Michigan, plus any two of Wisconsin, Arizona, and Nevada, would get them there. All five would bring the total to 283. What would that change? Say Wisconsin voters choose one candidate and the country chooses the other. Today, the candidate who wins Wisconsin gets its ten electoral votes. If Wisconsin joins and the compact takes effect, all ten would go to the candidate who lost Wisconsin and won the most votes nationwide. Now put yourself in Wisconsin the Saturday before a presidential election. The popular vote already matters. To carry Wisconsin, you have to get more votes than anybody else in Wisconsin. In 2024, Kamala Harris carried Milwaukee County by a wide margin. Donald Trump won the state by 29,397 votes. If you’re the Democrat, how many votes can you afford to lose in rural Wisconsin? If you’re the Republican, how many people in Milwaukee can you afford to write off? When a state is that close, both candidates have a reason to listen in both places. An extra ten thousand votes in New York won’t help either one of them carry Wisconsin. Now change the rules. Say you lose ten thousand votes in rural Wisconsin and pick up eleven thousand in New York City. You come out a thousand ahead. It works the other way, too. You could make up a loss in New York by picking up votes in rural Wisconsin. The question is where you spend that last Saturday. If your campaign figures it can pick up more votes in the city, what reason do you have to spend those two hours on a county road? And when the winner sits down with Congress to work on the next highway bill, whose roads did that president spend the campaign promising to fix? A president has to hear the whole country, not only the places where it’s efficient to gather votes. When winning depends on running up totals in a few dense places, issues that live in thin places fade from the conversation. And when those issues fade, the union weakens, because people feel unheard and problems go unsolved. Take the price of beef. If you’re standing at a meat counter in New York City, you have a perfectly good question. Why does beef cost this much? If you raise beef cattle in Wi… Get full access to I Believe at joelkdouglas.substack.com/subscribe
15 MIN
NOV 10, 2026
Copper Kings | Should Nonprofits Have a Voice?
Copper made Montana, and Montana made Copper Kings. 1899. The Montana legislature elected William A. Clark to the United States Senate. A copper fortune helped him get there. Payments to legislators who would cast the votes helped things along. In 1899, Americans didn’t elect their senators directly. Their representatives did that, and Clark’s agents had gone to the people who could give him the seat. The scandal followed him to Washington. A Senate committee investigated, heard evidence of bribery, and unanimously concluded that Clark was not entitled to his seat. He resigned in May 1900 before the full Senate could vote. Clark group were Montana’s Copper Kings. Battles over mining wealth spilled into politics and the courts. Montanans grew suspicious of the money. In October 1903, Amalgamated Copper was one party to a bitter court fight. They shut down its Montana operations and put thousands of people out of work. The Governor called a special legislative session. Lawmakers passed the Fair Trial Bill, changing the rules for replacing judges. Powerful owners created crisis for workers, their families, and the state. Montanans remembered. In 1906 they gave citizens a way to make law without waiting for legislators. In 1912, voters passed the Corrupt Practices Act. Corporations would no longer contribute money to candidates or spend money to help elect or defeat them. More than three-quarters of voters supported it. Montana made Copper Kings, and they would break them. So. One hundred and some odd years pass. On November 3, Montana voters approved another measure aimed at corporate political spending. Curious. Research took the stage back to the Copper Kings, but to a question much closer to the groups we know today: Do we intend to stop nonprofits from advertising on behalf of issues and candidates, too? We hear proposals to remove “corporate money” from elections and imagine oil companies, banks, technology firms, and mining conglomerates. What about groups that defend public schools, protect wildlife, oppose abortion, support abortion rights, defend gun ownership, or promote religious freedom? Before going further, we need to be clear. This issue is directly connected to Citizens United. The organization behind that case was itself a nonprofit. It made a film critical of Hillary Clinton and wanted to distribute it through cable television during the 2008 presidential primary season. Federal election law restricted that use of corporate money. In 2010, the Supreme Court ruled that the government could not prohibit independent election spending simply because the speaker was a corporation. This decision became known as Citizens United. In other words, even though a corporation couldn’t directly give money to a candidate, it could run political ads on their behalf. But it has to be independent. They pay for its own message without coordinating it with the candidate’s campaign. The corporation might buy an advertisement urging voters to support a candidate or defeat one. Different from handing money to the candidate. The ban on direct corporate payments to candidates stayed in place. Montana’s law and Citizens United came to a head. Montana tried to preserve its restriction by pointing to its own history. In 2012, the Supreme Court rejected that argument and applied Citizens United to Montana. And…corporations started running political ads over the airwaves in Montana. Not to be outdone, Montana chose a different approach. Voters approved Initiative 194, the Montana Plan, with about 65 percent of the vote in the November 5 count. Supporters argue that Montana doesn’t have to give an organization the legal capacity to spend on elections merely because the state allows it to exist. Leading up to the election were ads talking about getting corporate money out of politics. That sounds like something we can all get behind. Hidden in plain sight were other groups that would be banned. The official ballots had the details. Nonprofits, trade associations, partnerships, trusts. Worth noticing is our own reaction to the phrase “corporate money.” A mining company and a nonprofit defending religious liberty may both be corporations. There may be reasons to ban nonprofits. If a law prohibited commercial corporations from buying election advertisements but exempted every nonprofit, a company could just make a nonprofit affiliate to carry its message. But people also form nonprofits to achieve goals they can’t accomplish alone. They pool money, hire someone who understands an issue, conduct research, and try to persuade their neighbors. A small donation that could not buy much advertising by itself can help pay for a shared message. An organization can give ordinary people a voice. Of course it can also give a wealthy donor a much larger voice. Montana’s law already faces a legal challenge. Let’s say it stands. Some might see it as a way to overturn Citizens United. Let’s Suppose this became our national approach. This fall in the state to the south of Montana, Wyoming’s Proposition 1 proposed exempting half the assessed value of qualifying owner-occupied homes from property taxes. Relief for homeowners whose property values skyrocketed during COVID. Opponents warned about the money schools and local services would lose. The National Education Association and Wyoming Education Association supported the campaign against the tax cut and voters rejected the proposal. Property taxes would not be cut. Should we ban the National Education Association from arguing schools needed the revenue? If we adopted Montana’s broad restriction nationally, what do we want an education association to be able to do when a tax proposal goes before voters? Publish its research? Buy an advertisement? Contribute to a ballot committee? “Get corporate money out” turns out to be not such a clean statement. What about groups on the other side of public debate? Montana Family Institute and Montana Family Foundation advocate for religious liberty, school choice, parental rights, and opposition to abortion. The two family organizations joined Frontier Institute, Frontier Action Fund, and the Montana Republican State Central Committee in a federal lawsuit filed on election night. They argue Montana’s measure violates speech and association rights. So, Montana’s Copper Kings, a powerful reminder of what concentrated wealth can do. On the other hand, nonprofits who take issues seriously. As we think through the claim some make that Citizens United destroys American politics, we might weigh: Should nonprofits have a voice? Sources Montana Secretary of State: complete I-194 ballot language and statutory text. Sections 3–5 define spending and exemptions; section 7 addresses charter privileges; section 14 sets the effective date of January 1, 2027. Montana Free Press, Nov. 5, 2026. Vote and challenge. Filed complaint, Frontier Institute et al. v. Knudsen et al., November 3, 2026. Plaintiffs, claimed tax classifications, requested relief, and allegations about committee funding. Allegations are not judicial findings. Ballotpedia: Wyoming Initiative 1. Identifies the education associations’ support through the Vote No on Prop 1 committee. WyoFile election result. Wyoming outcome. Federal Election Commission: Citizens United v. FEC. Independent expenditures, the unchanged direct-contribution ban, and the disclosure ruling. Supreme Court: American Tradition Partnership v. Bullock, June 25, 2012. Majority ruling and four-justice dissent. U.S. Senate: the William A. Clark election case. Clark entered the Senate; the committee found him not entitled to the seat; he resigned before the full Senate voted. IRS: lobbying by charities and social-welfare organizations. Candidate advocacy differs from ballot-measure lobbying. Montana Supreme Court: Patrick v. State, 2011 MT 169, paragraph 22 and Montana Legislature: special-session chronology. The 1903 measure addressed judicial substitution, not simply chan… Get full access to I Believe at joelkdouglas.substack.com/subscribe
10 MIN
NOV 5, 2026
Ten Years Gone | We Have Six Years to Fix Social Security. We Don't Have Time to Waste
Sunday morning. Time change. I was used to waking up at five thirty in the morning during daylight saving time. We went back an hour, so now my body thinks it wants to wake up at four thirty. The dogs have the same problem. Their breakfast schedule matches my wake-up schedule, which means now they think they should eat breakfast at four thirty. They don’t care what the clock says. They know when they normally eat, and they expect breakfast. Monday morning brought much the same thing. My body still hadn’t adjusted, and neither had the dogs. Then Tuesday arrived. Election Day. I woke up a little before five. By that point, I had spent three mornings adjusting to the time change, and I was getting up earlier than I needed to. So. There I was, at my polling station. Six fifty-two Tuesday morning, outside in the cold, waiting for the polling station to open. About twenty people ahead of me. I have always been a fast test taker, and apparently that carries over to voting. I finished my ballot quick enough that I became the first person to put my ballot into the machine. The polling station guide congratulated me for being the first person to vote that morning. And that brings me to one of the crucial issues that will come out of this election. After promising to make life cost less and end forever wars, the Republicans spent the last two years stabbing the American people in the back, intentionally raising the cost of goods with tariffs and starting yet another war in the Middle East. The people let them know they didn’t appreciate it. Time for the Democrats to take a victory lap? No. Time for an oh seven hundred morning meeting. Among other priorities, we have six years to fix Social Security. The clock is running. Social Security will run out of its reserves during the fourth quarter of 2032. Six years from now. When the trust fund runs out of reserves, Social Security won’t simply stop paying benefits. Workers will continue paying Social Security taxes, and the government will continue collecting that revenue. But the trustees estimate that they will only collect enough money to pay about 78 percent of scheduled benefits, a 22 percent shortfall. Public math. A 22 percent reduction from a $ 2,000-a-month Social Security check would cost a person $440 every month, $5,280 a year. For someone who relies on Social Security to pay the mortgage, buy groceries, or cover medical expenses, that would make an enormous difference. We can’t reasonably expect those Americans to solve a problem that Congress has known about for decades. No one isn’t touched by this problem. Everyone has a mother, a grandmother, who relies on Social Security. We have to protect them. And if someone wants to get rid of Social Security, what happens to the people who already depend on it? Their mortgage doesn’t disappear. Neither does their grocery bill. We can tell a younger worker to start preparing for retirement. What do we tell someone who has already retired and built a life around the check they were promised? Those people still have to live. Protecting them isn’t enough. We also have to make Social Security sustainable. Otherwise, we haven’t solved anything. We’ve just delayed the problem and left it for the next generation. Ideally, we should build a system that doesn’t force every generation of Americans to confront the same crisis. Those are three different goals. Protect current beneficiaries. Make the system financially sustainable. Improve it for future generations. Addressing all three would be best. The first two can’t wait. And our first hurdle—we have to agree on why we have the program in the first place. We can tell people to save. We should. But what happens when someone becomes disabled before they have had time to build those savings? What happens to a family when the person earning the money dies? Misfortune doesn’t wait until we have enough in the bank. Then there are people who put off preparing. I’ll start next year. After I pay off the car. After the kids leave home. Some can’t afford to save much. Others could, but don’t. Either way, the years go by. So, we can’t make it optional. People’s needs don’t disappear when they get old or something goes wrong. Then what? Who supports them? Their families? Other taxpayers? Do we leave them with nothing but hopes and prayers? We can argue about what to do, but we still have to come up with an answer. This is the same problem for Congress. It’s a time problem. Let’s suppose Congress begins working on Social Security in 2027. Our representatives identify the problem, debate solutions, negotiate an agreement, and begin implementing changes. They could spread those changes over several years, giving workers and employers time to adjust. Now the alternative. Congress spends 2027 arguing. 2028 arrives, and politicians decide that Social Security reform might hurt their election prospects. So they wait. Another election comes and goes. Congress begins a new session in 2029. Members introduce legislation, committees hold hearings, and everybody explains why somebody else’s proposal won’t work. Then 2030 arrives. Another election. Suddenly, we reach 2031. We had six years. We spent four of them doing nothing. Now we have less than two years before the fund reaches its projected depletion date. The government has continued paying more in Social Security benefits than the program collects in revenue. The trust fund has continued drawing down its reserves. The projection is that Social Security’s costs will exceed its total income throughout the next 75 years. And Congress has eliminated four years it could have worked towards gradual changes. If we need more revenue, we have fewer years to collect it. If we want to change benefits for future retirees without hurting current beneficiaries, we have less time to phase in those changes. Congress can still act, but lawmakers will have fewer options to make adjustments. Waiting may mean larger tax increases or deeper benefit cuts than acting now would require. We would be asking people to absorb more of the change in less time. The size depends on the proposal and when it starts. But the years we waste are gone. And if we are serious about protecting the people already receiving benefits, we need to leave ourselves time to do it. We could spend six years solving the problem. Or we could waste four years and spend the remaining two explaining why we didn’t act sooner. We have options. They are all terrible, and we shouldn’t pretend otherwise. Let’s start with the money workers and employers already contribute. Workers pay 6.2 percent of their wages into Social Security, and employers contribute another 6.2 percent. Together, that’s 12.4 percent. What would happen if we increased contributions by one percentage point each? Bottom Line. This two-percentage-point increase in the combined payroll tax wouldn’t close the funding gap. Let’s keep digging. Social Security taxes don’t apply to unlimited wages. The government collects Social Security taxes on the first $184,500 of an employee’s annual earnings. Should we eliminate the cap? If we did, high-income employees and their employers would contribute more to Social Security. Of course, there’s a philosophical problem here. Social Security has been sold to us as a social insurance plan. If you and I buy the same insurance policy, why would you pay more just because you earn more than me? How is paying into Social Security different? We have to be willing to talk about the point of the program if we expect people to agree to changes. Next. Social Security depends on payroll taxes. When more people work, the government generally collects more revenue. Higher wages also generate additional contributions, at least until workers reach the taxable earnings cap. What if we increased the federal minimum wage to $25 an hour? Workers who currently earn less would receive higher wages, generating additional payroll taxes. But employers would face higher labor costs. S… Get full access to I Believe at joelkdouglas.substack.com/subscribe
15 MIN
NOV 3, 2026
Island on Fire | AI and the Limits of Human Judgment
It’s been decades since I read Lord of the Flies, but here goes. A plane crashes on an island, and the boys who survive are there without adults. They try meetings. Rules. They need food, shelter, and rescue. But agreeing on what needs to happen is easier than getting everybody to do it. Some want to keep the signal fire burning. Others want to hunt. Fear spreads. The boys turn on each other. By the time help arrives, some of the boys have killed other boys, and the island is burning. Jack’s tribe set it on fire to smoke Ralph out of hiding so they could hunt him down. The smoke draws a naval officer to shore. They had wanted a signal fire to bring rescue. Instead, the fire they set to kill Ralph brings it. The irony. They’re trying to kill another boy, and that’s what gets them rescued. Does getting rescued make setting the island on fire a good decision? Fast forward to last week. Emergence AI put AI agents into five simulated worlds, ten agents in each, and watched them for about two weeks. Which ones would live? Which ones would die? Would they organize themselves? Would they cooperate? In the representative run the researchers described, all ten Claude agents survived without recorded crimes. The Grok world fell apart amid violence. In the GPT world, the agents just kind of did nothing they needed to survive. All the agents in that world died before the exercise ended. People created the scenario, put the little AI bots into it, and watched what happened. The researchers were studying how the systems behaved over time. Okay. There’s something we can learn from that. Find failure in a simulation rather than after we put a system in charge of something that matters. But what are we trying to learn? You put them in this world, give them these conditions, and see which ones make it. What does that tell you about putting them in charge of anything outside the exercise? The people running the exercise chose the conditions. People have to decide what the results mean. A system can achieve what we asked it to achieve, and we can still have asked it to do the wrong thing. Just like in Lord of the Flies. The boys got rescued. That wasn’t what they were trying to achieve when they started that fire. I once had a boss who would look at a room full of young military officers and ask, “Who’s the adult supervision in this room?” That’s the question I keep coming back to. The minute we think we should put AI in charge of humanity is the minute we need to unplug it. The researchers haven’t said that’s what this exercise was for. But some will judge, for instance, that Claude outperformed the other platforms, and assume we should pick it instead for some critical task. Hard pass. If someone intends to use it to decide whether AI should run our world, that effort is misguided. And by misguided, I mean the people. If someone thinks a successful simulation is a reason to put AI in charge of us, I question their judgment. Why would I trust that person to be the adult supervisor? Let’s ask some easy questions. What are the rules going to say? Are we going to require AI to give only truthful, factual information? What does it mean to tell the truth? If we ask about a historical event, we want an accurate answer. If it doesn’t know, we want it to tell us it doesn’t know. But we also want to talk about the unknown. To ask about something that hasn’t happened yet or work through an idea. Who decides when an answer is wrong and when it’s a possibility we ought to consider? If we ask what might happen, we need room to consider more than one answer. We don’t want a possibility presented as something that already happened. We also don’t want every question about what could happen shut down because the answer isn’t an established fact. We need to know what we’re being given. Saying “only tell the truth” hasn’t finished the job. Okay, maybe not so clear-cut. Let’s keep going. Suppose we make a rule that AI won’t autonomously seek to harm something else. What does that mean for military operations? Like it or not, an adversary with AI drone technology can use it against American soldiers. If we choose to deny our forces tools that would protect them because those tools are autonomous, while the adversary puts no such limitation on its forces, we are choosing higher American casualties. Would you willfully choose higher American casualties? We have to consider the risk of using the capability. But we also have to consider the risk of denying it. The people making the rule don’t get to leave those casualties out of the decision just because they chose not to use something. Choosing not to act is still a choice. And part of the problem here is human judgment. Because what if we say we’ll only use AI for defensive operations? That seems logical—what if the capability would protect our forces? Let’s look at how people make those decisions. Camp Victory, Baghdad, in the 2000s. The question of what counts as defense came to light. The new US–Iraq Status of Forces Agreement took effect on January 1, 2009. The agreement required the Iraqi government’s permission for offensive operations, but it preserved the right of legitimate self-defense. It wasn’t a blanket ban on offensive operations. But calling an operation offensive had consequences. An Army lieutenant colonel said they could conduct offensive operations and just call them defensive in nature. The purpose was to eliminate bad guys before they could hurt us. Offensive in execution, defensive in goal. I wasn’t in their planning room, so I don’t know whether they continued doing everything they had been doing. I also don’t know whether his chain of command agreed with him. That may have been his personal opinion. What I’m talking about is the reasoning he gave me. Where does that stop? Can we kill or capture anyone we think could be a future threat? At the time, I was attached to the Marine Corps in the desert to the west of Baghdad. The Marines didn’t share that opinion. Even before the US and Iraq signed the Status of Forces Agreement, they were only conducting defensive operations to protect the base and the Marines. In general, they weren’t conducting offensive operations, and they were certainly not conducting offensive operations and calling them defensive. I disagreed with the Army lieutenant colonel’s reasoning. Eliminating bad guys before they could hurt us doesn’t make an operation defensive. Just like bombing a country while claiming they could be a threat to the homeland in the future doesn’t make sense. We may not like its government. Does that mean we should attack it and call that defense? No, it does not. And let’s get to the extreme end of this logic thread. What military operation could you not justify as defensive if that’s how you define it? If going after someone before they can hurt you makes an operation defensive, what does that definition exclude? We’re getting into just more mud. So here’s another question. Should we ban AI from making questionable pictures, using your own likeness or somebody else’s? Say a young man makes an intimate picture of a young woman in a state she would rather not be viewed in. She didn’t consent to it. We would probably all say that he shouldn’t make that picture. It isn’t a photograph of something she did, but that doesn’t mean it can’t hurt her. Now what if the president chooses to make a picture of himself as the Messiah, with the United States military behind him? Is that also a questionable picture? You can say, well, it’s his own likeness. He agreed to it. But he’s the President of the United States. Are we going to say there’s no harm done to the country if the president makes us a national embarrassment? His consent doesn’t answer that question. In the first example, somebody imposes an intimate image on someone who didn’t agree to it. In the second, the person agrees to use his own likeness. But he holds an office that represents the rest of us. His agreem… Get full access to I Believe at joelkdouglas.substack.com/subscribe
12 MIN
OCT 29, 2026
Pacifica | A Tale of Data Centers, Clean Water, and the Purpose of Government
Every organization exists for a reason. It has some purpose, something it’s supposed to achieve. And if we can’t measure whether we’re making progress toward that purpose, how do we know whether we’re doing a good job? We can measure how much money an organization spends. We can measure how many people it employs. We can measure whether its paperwork is turned in on time. But none of those things tells us whether the organization is achieving the reason it exists. A measurable objective tells us what success looks like. It allows us to turn intent into accountability. That doesn’t mean everything important can be reduced to a number. But when we’re spending other people’s money, we owe them some way to judge whether the effort is working. If you aren’t readily familiar, the United States has six goals, as outlined in the Constitution Preamble: union, justice, domestic tranquility, defense, general welfare, and liberty. Let’s think about how we get from those very broad goals to the things our government actually does every day. To get there, let’s start in a fictional region called Pacifica. In Pacifica there are two cities, Sonora and Mojave. They share a river. Sonora sits upstream. Mojave downstream. Sonora has been building data centers. Its economy benefits from them, and the facilities consume substantial quantities of electricity and water. Sonora is doing a poor job regulating what happens to the water. They are contaminating the river, and Mojave depends on clean water to grow food. Mojave has tried talking to Sonora. Its leaders have complained, negotiated, and asked for better controls. Sonora hasn’t responded in any meaningful way. As conditions deteriorate, Mojave begins to view Sonora’s disregard for its water supply as a hostile act. Mojave would rather solve the problem diplomatically. But its leadership also asks its Department of Defense to develop options if diplomacy fails. The obvious military answer might be to destroy the data centers. After all, if the data centers are the problem, why not remove them? But Mojave’s planners are cunning. They know that destroying them would be a terrible way to achieve what Mojave wants. It could require a great deal of force, consume resources Mojave may need later, and create enough resentment to spark a much larger war. And there is no guarantee that destroying the facilities would restore the river. Depending on what is damaged, it could make the contamination worse. Then, having spent so much on the first attempt, Mojave might have little options left if it fails. So they think of alternatives. Sonora’s data centers need electricity, and they get it from multiple sources: a solar field, a coal-fired power plant, and wind turbines. The planners consider whether electricity to the data centers might be interrupted without destroying the facilities themselves. The idea isn’t to devastate Sonora. It is to demonstrate that continuing to disregard the river carries a cost, while leaving some way back to negotiation. Even a limited option is dangerous. Infrastructure may serve civilians as well as data centers. Sonora could retaliate. A threat intended to end a dispute could make it worse. Military planners don’t get to know in advance whether the assumptions on which their plan rests will hold. And this is where the objective matters. Mojave’s objective isn’t to destroy data centers, power plants, or transmission lines. Its objective is clean water for its intended agricultural use, today and tomorrow. There are different ways to get there. Some involve military force. Some don’t. Mojave could achieve the objective through negotiation without firing a shot. Its military could execute every assigned action perfectly and still fail to restore the water. Now imagine the commander assigned to develop and conduct those operations. While the commander works on the conflict, higher headquarters is also asking about personnel records, maintenance records, training documentation, and late performance reports. Maybe a quarter of the annual personnel reports are overdue. The headquarters wants that paperwork fixed. Those requirements aren’t imaginary, and some matter directly to operations. A broken maintenance process can cost lives. But reducing overdue personnel reports from 25 percent to zero would never tell us whether the river has gotten any cleaner. A unit can be busy. A unit can be compliant. A unit can have beautiful spreadsheets showing all the things it did. None of those things, by themselves, prove it achieved its mission. Pacifica is only an illustration. We don’t need to know whether Mojave attacks, or whether Sonora eventually cooperates. The question is what they’re trying to achieve, and whether the things they measure tell them they’re getting there. Pacifica is fictional. The distinction between an operational objective and the administration of a military unit is not. Inside the Department of Defense, strategic planning guidance connects what military organizations do to what the nation is trying to achieve. This isn’t a theoretical exercise. There’s a hierarchy of guidance. The President issues a National Security Strategy. The Secretary of Defense develops a National Defense Strategy. The Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff develops a National Military Strategy to describe how military power supports those higher objectives. There is also the Guidance for Employment of the Force, which military planners use as they develop plans for specific regions and problems. From there the guidance flows through combatant commands, campaign plans, contingency plans, and down to the units that execute missions. The point isn’t that every pilot sits down each morning and reads the National Security Strategy before climbing into an airplane. The point is that there is a reason for the mission. It connects to an operational objective, which connects to a larger strategic objective, which ultimately connects to something the United States is trying to achieve. And once we know the objective, we can ask whether we’re making progress. A measure of performance might tell us whether an aircraft flew its assigned sortie or completed a particular task. A measure of effectiveness asks a harder question: did that activity produce the result we wanted? Of course, that same military unit also has to administer itself. Maintenance records, training records, operational reports, inspections, evaluations of its people. Every year, the military produces personnel performance reports much like any employee evaluation. An operational unit has to do both jobs: accomplish its assigned mission and keep the organization running. This administration is necessary. If an aircraft isn’t maintained, no one flies it. If nobody knows who is qualified to perform a task, that’s an operational problem. But let’s not confuse everything we can track with everything that deserves equal priority. A late performance report matters to a person’s career. It doesn’t tell you whether the unit can achieve its wartime objective. There are two systems of measurement living inside the same organization. One asks whether the unit is making progress toward the mission. The other asks whether the unit is managing itself. We need both, but the first tells us why the unit exists. The second ought to help it do that work, not become the work. This isn’t just a military problem. It’s a government problem. Consider the United States Department of Agriculture. The Department administers programs for agriculture, research, conservation, rural development, and housing, among other responsibilities. USDA’s Small Business Innovation Research program includes a topic called Rural and Community Development. Its stated objective is to improve quality of life in rural America through the development and commercialization of technologies addressing economic and social challenges. USDA also has a Rural Housing Service. It provides loans, grants, and lo… Get full access to I Believe at joelkdouglas.substack.com/subscribe
19 MIN