/https%3A%2F%2Ffeeds.alitu.com%2F67379866%2F78224e48-577a-4eda-9297-1c2e7eb0c0ac.jpg%3Ft%3D1775322331000)
Paper Leash
Lori Meg
DEVELOPING STORY: ROMANCH'S LAW The 168-Year Industry That Just Killed an 18-Year-Old Tourist —
JUL 17, 202632 MIN
/https%3A%2F%2Ffeeds.alitu.com%2F67379866%2F78224e48-577a-4eda-9297-1c2e7eb0c0ac.jpg%3Ft%3D1775322331000)
Description
This is a developing story. It does not end with a verdict. Because the story isn't over yet.
On June 17, 2026, at 2:47 in the afternoon, a family from India booked a horse-drawn carriage ride in Central Park. It was their first visit to New York City. The driver stepped away from his horse to take a photo of his passengers. Nobody was holding the reins. The horse bolted. Romanch Mahajan, 18 years old, watched his mother fall from the carriage — and jumped out to help her. His head hit the pavement. He died that evening.
His father Deepak told the New York Times: "My son, just to save his mother, he fell off."
It was the first human death in a carriage incident in Central Park history.
And it was the most recent chapter in a story that has been unfolding in this city for 168 years.
The ASPCA was founded in 1866 specifically in response to carriage horse abuse in New York City. Its original seal depicts a carriage operator beating a horse. A century and a half later, we are still having this conversation.
In this episode: how the industry actually works, who profits, why a $70 million business backed by one of America's most powerful transit unions has survived decades of pressure to shut it down, what the named horses — Aisha, Lady, Ryder — have in common, what the driver did on June 17th and why he hasn't been charged, what Romanch's Law would do, and what both sides said at the New York City Council hearing on July 15, 2026.
The carriage horse industry has two sides. Both of them are in this episode. This is Paperleash — we follow the paper. We let you decide.
But a boy is dead. And his father is on Zoom from India. And the industry's own union says the driver violated their protocols.
This is a crime the system hasn't counted yet.
Stay obsessed. Stay skeptical. Stay loud.
FULL SHOW NOTES
THIS IS A DEVELOPING STORY
This episode was recorded on July 15 and 16, 2026 — the day of and the day after the New York City Council Health Committee hearing on Romanch's Law (Intro 943). No vote has been scheduled. Romanch Mahajan's driver has not been charged. The bill may pass. It may die in committee.
Paperleash will cover what comes next. Follow wherever you get your podcasts to be notified when the follow-up episode drops.
ROMANCH MAHAJAN — WHO HE WAS
Romanch Mahajan was 18 years old. A young man from India on his family's first trip to New York City. He was in Central Park on June 17, 2026 with his parents — Deepak and Priya Mahajan — on what should have been a memory.
When Priya fell from the runaway carriage, Romanch did not hesitate. He jumped out to help her. His head hit the pavement. He was taken to NewYork-Presbyterian Weill Cornell Medical Center in critical condition. He died that evening.
His father Deepak testified before the New York City Council Health Committee via Zoom from India on July 15, 2026. He said:
"I cannot properly describe to you the real true fear inside that carriage. It was shaking. It was speeding. There was no one holding the reins, and we could do nothing but hold on to each other and scream."
"My son, just to save his mother, he fell off."
Romanch's aunt, Sovia Thukral, also testified at the July 15 hearing. She broke into tears at the witness table.
His death was the first human fatality in a carriage incident in Central Park history.
THE DRIVER AND THE HORSE
Ertan Gokdepe — licensed carriage driver, member of TWU Local 100. On June 17, 2026, he stepped away from his horse to photograph his passengers. He was, according to the union's own representative, at least "an arm's length" from his horse when Sampson bolted.
Alexander Kemp, Administrative Vice President of TWU Local 100, said publicly:
"A driver is not supposed to leave the carriage to take photos — ever."
The union acknowledged the violation of their own protocols immediately.
Sampson — a 7-year-old horse who had been working in Central Park for six weeks. He was retired from service following the incident.
As of July 15, 2026: Ertan Gokdepe has not been charged with any crime. The NYPD investigation is ongoing. The question of whether his conduct rises to criminal negligence is before the Manhattan DA's office, which has not publicly commented.
HOW THE INDUSTRY ACTUALLY WORKS
Not the romantic image. The financial reality.
68 licensed carriage medallions exist in New York City. The city stopped issuing new ones after World War II. A single medallion today sells for upwards of $300,000.
208 licensed drivers are currently active. The drivers are not the same as the medallion owners — in many cases, drivers pay to operate under a medallion owner's license. NYCLASS has characterized the drivers as misclassified independent contractors with no benefits, no overtime, and no guaranteed wage.
150+ horses currently stabled at Clinton Park Stables on West 52nd Street, Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan.
Fares set by city law: $72.22 for the first 20 minutes. $28.89 for each additional 10 minutes.
$70 million — estimated value of stable assets held by medallion owners (NYCLASS estimate).
$100,000/month — estimated cost of caring for all horses in the city (TWU estimate, funded by ride revenue).
The union: TWU Local 100 represents the carriage horse drivers. It also represents 40,000 subway and bus workers at the MTA — making it one of the most powerful labor forces in New York City politics. When TWU Local 100 treats a vote on carriage horses as a labor issue, that message carries the weight of 40,000 transit workers behind it.
THE NAMED HORSES — THEY DESERVE TO BE NAMED
Aisha — 2020. Video surfaced of carriage drivers blowing smoke into her face as she lay on the ground and flipped over in terror. NYCLASS documented 17 minutes of footage. Animal cruelty charges were called for. No charges were filed.
Lady — 2022. Died in a separate incident that reignited advocacy pressure.
Ryder — August 2022. A 14-year-old horse who collapsed in Hell's Kitchen in 84-degree heat after working since 9:30am with no water. His driver, Ian McKeever, 54, repeatedly pulled on his reins, yelled at him, and flogged him with a whip as he lay on the street unable to stand. Cell phone video went viral. McKeever was eventually arraigned on one count of overdriving, torturing, and injuring an animal — a Class A misdemeanor. Ryder was euthanized months later. One misdemeanor. For working a horse to death without water in 84-degree heat. Then flogging him as he lay dying.
Sampson — June 17, 2026. Retired from service after the incident that killed Romanch Mahajan.
The pattern in the year before Romanch's death:
Last year: tourists jumped from a speeding runaway carriage
May 26, 2026: two carriages collided in Central Park, hospitalizing both drivers
The week before June 17: a horse died after eating a poisonous plant
June 17, 2026: Romanch Mahajan — the first human death
Eight incidents in just over a year.
THE HISTORY — 168 YEARS
The carriages have been operating in and around Central Park since the 1850s.
1866: The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals — the ASPCA — was founded in New York City specifically in response to carriage horse abuse. The organization's original seal depicts a carriage operator beating a horse. That is who we were in 1866. That is what the ASPCA was founded to stop.
The fight has cycled through the same stages for over a century: a horse collapses or dies, activists demand a ban, politicians promise action, the union pushes back, a compromise is reached — usually poorly enforced regulations — and the industry continues.
2013: Bill de Blasio ran for mayor on an explicit campaign promise to ban carriage horses on his first day in office. He won. He served for twelve years. He did not ban carriage horses.
What's different now: For the first time in 168 years, a human being has died. City Council Speaker Julie Mendin publicly supports the ban. Mayor Zohran Mamdani supports its spirit. The political alignment between Speaker and Mayor is genuinely new.
THE JULY 15, 2026 CITY COUNCIL HEARING
The New York City Council Health Committee held a full public hearing on Romanch's Law (Intro 943) on July 15, 2026.
Who testified for the ban:
Deepak Mahajan — Romanch's father, via Zoom from India. Described the terror inside the runaway carriage. "My son, just to save his mother, he fell off."
Sovia Thukral — Romanch's aunt. Broke into tears at the witness table.
Edie Falco — actress, The Sopranos. Lifelong New Yorker. Has been fighting for this ban for forty years. Testified in person. Said:
"They have the right to a God-given — if that's what you believe — life, just as we do. The fact that there's anybody in this room that can look at an animal with the apparatus and the carriage and the people and the traffic and the sounds and the smells and the heat and say 'sure, yeah, that's reasonable' — the first time I saw that, 40 years ago, I thought: what is this?"
"It's time. It's time. It's time."
City Council Speaker Julie Menin: "The time to act is now. Nearly 70 percent of New Yorkers are supportive of phasing out this practice."
Who testified against the ban:
Alexander Kemp, TWU Local 100: "The legacy of the horse and carriage rides are synonymous with New York. We have to collectively figure out how to make it a safer industry."
Christina Hansen, TWU Local 100 driver: "Why weren't we here about banning tourist helicopters after six passengers died — or banning pedicabs when a driver died?"
Conner McHugh, medallion owner: Raised the real estate angle — the allegation that developer interest in Hell's Kitchen stables property is driving the ban campaign.
Onur Altintas, carriage owner: "The industry provides hundreds of jobs to drivers, stable hands, and others in horse-related trades. Car crashes and plane crashes are happening every single day."
Status after the hearing: No vote was scheduled. The hearing was the first step in the legislative process, not the last. Council Member Marte's staff said he is optimistic that with Speaker Menin's support, passage is "just a matter of time."
ROMANCH'S LAW — INTRO 943
Sponsor: Council Member Christopher Marte (D-Manhattan, District 1)
What it does:
Ends issuance of new horse carriage licenses immediately upon passage
Prohibits all horse carriage operations in New York City effective June 1, 2028
Requires NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection to establish a workforce development program for displaced drivers
Prohibits horses from being sold for slaughter or transferred to another carriage industry
Mandates humane disposition of all retired horses
Status as of July 16, 2026:
Public hearing completed July 15, 2026
No vote date set
Speaker Menin's support expected to allow scheduling of a full Council vote
Mayor Mamdani has not committed to signing as written — wants stronger worker protections
THE UNANSWERED QUESTIONS
Will Ertan Gokdepe be charged? The NYPD investigation is ongoing. The Manhattan DA's office has not commented publicly. Ian McKeever was charged with a misdemeanor for flogging a dying horse. The question of what charge is appropriate when a driver's protocol violation results in a human death has not been answered.
Will Romanch's Law pass? The votes appear close to majority. But "close to majority" has happened before and collapsed under TWU pressure. The union's full political mobilization — advertising, endorsement threats, the weight of 40,000 transit workers — has not yet fully deployed.
What happens to the horses? The bill requires humane disposition. 150 horses over a two-year phase-out period need sanctuaries, farms, and funding. That infrastructure needs to be real. The bill's opponents are not wrong to raise this.
Who is really funding both sides? NYCLASS co-founder Steve Nislick is a real estate developer. Clinton Park Stables on West 52nd Street sits on prime Hell's Kitchen real estate. The union's allegation that developer money is driving the advocacy campaign has never been definitively proven or disproven. That money trail matters.
THE CELEBRITIES WHO SUPPORT THE BAN (documented)
Joaquin Phoenix, Billie Eilish, Finneas, Ricky Gervais, Sarah Silverman, Christopher Walken, Joan Jett, Kesha, Hilary Swank, Justin Theroux, Marisa Tomei, Kate Mara, Rooney Mara, Kaley Cuoco, Whitney Cummings, Noah Cyrus, Sadie Sink, Riley Keough, Christian Serratos, Christian Siriano, Geezer Butler (Black Sabbath), Maggie Baird, Edie Falco (testified in person July 15, 2026).
KEY PEOPLE — ALL VERIFIED
Romanch Mahajan, 18 — tourist from India. Killed June 17, 2026. First human death in a Central Park carriage incident in history. Jumped from a runaway carriage to help his mother. His death is the reason Intro 943 was renamed Romanch's Law.
Deepak Mahajan — Romanch's father. Testified via Zoom from India, July 15, 2026.
Priya Mahajan — Romanch's mother. Fell from the carriage. Survived with minor injuries.
Sovia Thukral — Romanch's aunt. Testified at the July 15 hearing.
Ertan Gokdepe — the driver. Stepped away to photograph passengers. Suspended. Not charged as of July 16, 2026.
Sampson — 7-year-old horse. Working in the park for six weeks. Retired after the incident.
Ian McKeever, 54 — driver in the Ryder case. Arraigned on one count of overdriving, torturing, and injuring an animal — Class A misdemeanor. Ryder died months later.
Council Member Christopher Marte (D-Manhattan, District 1) — bill sponsor. → council.nyc.gov/district-1
Council Speaker Julie Menin — publicly supports the ban.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani — supports the ban's spirit, wants stronger worker protections.
Council Majority Leader Shaun Abreu — announced support for the ban July 6, 2026.
Edie Falco — testified in person July 15. Has been fighting this fight for 40 years.
Alexander Kemp — Administrative VP, TWU Local 100. Acknowledged driver violated protocols.
Christina Hansen — carriage driver, TWU Local 100 representative.
Steve Nislick — co-founder and president of NYCLASS. Real estate developer.
THE NUMBERS
StatFigure
Licensed carriage medallions in NYC68 (capped since post-WWII)
Price of a single medallion$300,000+
Licensed carriage drivers~208
Horses currently stabled in Manhattan150+
Estimated medallion owner stable assets$70 million (NYCLASS)
Monthly cost of horse care~$100,000 (TWU estimate)
City-regulated fare (first 20 min)$72.22
NYers supporting a ban~70% (Speaker Menin citing polling)
Carriage incidents in the past year8
Years the industry has operated168
TAKE ACTION
Contact your NYC Council member: council.nyc.gov — find your representative and tell them where you stand on Romanch's Law (Intro 943)
Contact the bill's sponsor: Council Member Christopher Marte — council.nyc.gov/district-1
NYCLASS: nyclass.org
Animal Legal Defense Fund: aldf.org/project/romanchs-law
PETA NYC carriage horse action alert: peta.org
SOURCES
Gothamist — July 15, 2026 hearing coverage
amNewYork — July 15, 2026 City Council hearing
W42ST — Edie Falco testimony, July 15, 2026
ABC7 New York — July 13 and 15, 2026
NBC New York — June 17 and July 15, 2026
PIX11 — Mayor Mamdani response; hearing coverage
City and State New York — "A Brief History of New York City's Neverending Horse Carriage Controversy," July 13, 2026
City and State New York — "Legislation to ban horse carriages nears majority support," July 8, 2026
CBS New York — Romanch Mahajan death coverage, June 2026
NY Post / AOL — Deepak Mahajan family account
West Side Rag — "Facing a Ban, Carriage Drivers Defend Their Industry," October 2025
PETA — Edie Falco letter to NYC Mayor, September 2025
NYCLASS — "Setting the Record Straight" on TWU Local 100, October 2025
TWU Local 100 — twulocal100.org
Humane World for Animals — "Will the NYC carriage horse era finally draw to a close?" February and June 2026
Animal Legal Defense Fund — Romanch's Law petition
NBC News — Ian McKeever charged in Ryder case
ABOUT THIS EPISODE FORMAT
This is Paperleash's first developing story episode — a format we will use when a story is breaking and too important to wait for a resolution that may be weeks or months away. The episode presents both sides fully. It documents what is known and what is not. And it commits to a follow-up episode when the next significant development occurs.
The follow-up episode will cover: whether Ertan Gokdepe is charged, the outcome of the Council vote on Romanch's Law, and the fate of the 150 horses currently stabled in Manhattan.
Follow Paperleash wherever you get your podcasts to be notified when it drops.
ABOUT PAPERLEASH
Paperleash investigates the cases prosecutors dismiss, legislators ignore, and corporations bury. The crimes that don't count — because the victims never got a voice in the courtroom.
Every episode follows the paper trail. Every episode is an act of advocacy.
I'm Lori. Stay obsessed. Stay skeptical. Stay loud.

