/https://artwork.captivate.fm/5143d80a-1fa1-41c2-b8ff-82287cf9c5aa/Podmastery-Podcasting-Insights-June-2026-artwork.jpg)
Podmastery: podcasting insights and advice for indie creators
The Podmaster (Neal Veglio)
Podcast Advice Is A Banquet. Stop Trying To Eat All Of It.
NOV 16, 202611 MIN
/https://artwork.captivate.fm/f9a0d907-a963-4548-aff5-45e4f5f1bfa2/Stop-eating-all-of-it.jpg)
Description
I built a tool that judges podcasts. I pointed it at my own show. It marked me down for following my own advice.
The free health check gave Podmastery seven and a half out of eight, and told me I had an issue with my feed settings. I didn't. So I went into my own code, and found my tool agreed with me and had just worded it badly. The half point went on my release rhythm and my episode lengths, which is awkward, because in episode 97 I told you to let the idea decide how long an episode should be.
So who's right, me or the tool I built? Both, and neither. Because it's guidance, not rules, and so is every bit of podcast advice you've ever been given, mine included. Think of it as a banquet: you pick what you actually want to feast on. But first you work out what's plumbing (the stuff that breaks if you ignore it) and what's taste. Then you let your gut pick what to try, and let the numbers decide, once there are enough of them. My "most engaged episode ever" on Spotify turned out to be three people.
Your one thing is at 09:55 if you want to skip straight to it.
Podmastery: Podcasting Insights is for people who already make a podcast and are sick of being told they're doing it wrong.
Chapters
00:00 My own tool marked me down
04:27 Podcast advice is a banquet
07:06 Your gut picks, the numbers decide
09:55 Your one thing
Links
The free podcast health check (score out of 8 for your feed, red, amber and green): https://podmastery.co/health-check
When it's bigger than one bit of advice: https://podmastery.co/need-podcasting-help
Free 7-day podcast makeover email course: https://podmastery.co
Listener survey (free download as a thank-you): https://podmastery.co/listener-survey

