Ep 224| Last Year's Donors Are This Year's Opportunity

Send us Fan Mail You pulled the report. 1,800 people who gave last year haven't given a cent this year. And it's October. Cue Giving Season panic. Jena Lynch and Britt Stockert see it differently. Most of those lapsed donors didn't leave. They drifted. This episode is all about winning back LYBUNT donors (Last Year But Unfortunately Not This) before December 3 - no guilt trips. No "we miss you" emails. These donors already said yes once. That counts for a lot. Donors with a giving history come back 66% of the time. New donors come back just 24% of the time. And there's still time. Last year, December brought in 37% of nonprofits' online revenue. Britt shares the exact voicemail she'd leave a lapsed donor, and makes the case for skipping the ask in the first message (yes, even in October). Jena brings the gym membership comparison nobody wanted, but everybody needed. Got 30 minutes this week? Britt's action plan at the end is built for exactly that. What You'll Learn Why and how "hasn't given yet" and "gone for good" are two very different lists The unglamorous check that saves a lot of awkward emails How to pick 30 personal calls from a list of 1,800 (hint: not by gift size) Who in the organization should really be making those calls What to do when a donor leaves you on read How to ask in December without sounding like a final notice The one thing every fundraiser should do on their phone today A LYBUNT report shows who hasn't given. It can't show why. Before assuming the worst, check the data. Then start a conversation. As Jena puts it, "You are a nonprofit fundraiser, you are not a debt collector." Chapters: 00:00 That report you've been avoiding 01:00 LYBUNT: the acronym Britt loves 03:25 The 24% vs 66% gap 04:09 Check before you reach out 06:02 Bounced emails and the Promotions tab myth 07:13 1,800 names, 30 phone calls 08:01 The biggest gift isn't always the best relationship 10:05 First touch: skip the ask 10:47 The voicemail you should leave 13:02 Ask a question, not for money 16:04 When donors leave you on read 17:03 Adjusting expectations 18:08 The December ask that actually lands 18:50 A nonprofit, not a debt collector 21:02 Your 30-minute action plan Jena Lynch, Head of Community Engagement at Donorbox, and Britt Stockert, Fundraiser Coach at Donorbox, co-host this episode. Together, they bring hands-on experience helping nonprofits strengthen donor relationships and build fundraising systems that hold up under pressure...especially in Giving Season! Links Mentioned M+R Benchmarks study Ep 192| Donor-Advised Funds: What Fundraisers Need to Know Now with Cara Augspurger  Donorbox: donorbox.org  About Donorbox Donorbox is a global fundraising platform trusted by 100,000+ nonprofits, with $4B+ raised worldwide.   This podcast is for educational purposes only and is not legal or financial advice. Consult a professional advisor. Support the show