The ThoughtStretchers Podcast

ThoughtStretchers Education

A Rebirth of American Education: The Phoenix Principles

NOV 16, 202662 MIN

Description

Drew Perkins talks with James Shuls, head of the Educational Liberty branch of Florida State University's Institute for Governance and Civics and co-editor, with Jason Bedrick of the Heritage Foundation, of The Phoenix Principles. The book grew out of a conservative convening that set out to say what education reformers are for, not just what they're against, and it lays out seven principles: parents as primary educators, transparency and accountability, truth and goodness, character formation, academic excellence, cultural transmission and the formation of citizens. James explains why the group framed it as an American vision rather than a conservative one, and he and Drew dig into the tensions: parents' rights and the state's role in civic education, school choice and federalism, book bans and "haggling over the price," shared cultural knowledge versus the trivialization of civics, and where explicit instruction and inquiry each belong. They close on what a Phoenix Principles education would produce: a more measured society, more boring politics, and citizens who recognize the dignity of the people they disagree with. Links & Resources If you enjoyed this episode, please share it and please leave a review on Apple Podcasts. Have some feedback you'd like to share? You can email me at [email protected] Intro/outro voice credit: David O'Hara, Professor of Philosophy, Classics & Environmental Studies, Augustana University. Key takeaways Say what you're for: The Phoenix Declaration began at a convening of conservative education reformers who wanted to stop playing whack-a-mole against what they opposed and articulate a positive vision. The book expands its seven principles into essays that give readers the arguments to defend them. Education is formation, not just job prep: James argues that schools should transmit cultural knowledge and values, form character and form American citizens. Preparing people for jobs matters, but it isn't the whole purpose. Parents first, but the state isn't neutral: Parents have the pre-political right to direct their children's upbringing. The state still has an interest in forming citizens, and school choice acts as a check if the state gets too heavy-handed. Everyone is haggling over the price: Whether it's book bans or rules for private schools in choice programs, nearly everyone draws a line somewhere. James prefers letting states experiment over uniform national rules. Knowledge, not trivia: Content knowledge is essential, but turning civics into trivia doesn't make good citizens. Students need to wrestle with primary sources and opposing arguments, with time for both direct instruction and inquiry. Aim for more boring politics: A Phoenix Principles education, James hopes, would produce a more measured society that understands majority rule, minority rights and the dignity of people we disagree with. Episode highlights and timecodes 0:00 – Introduction: James Shuls and Florida State's Institute for Governance and Civics. 1:48 – Civic pragmatism and the four pillars of liberty: Great books plus statistics, and the new Civics and Liberty Studies degree. 3:45 – Will civics institutes survive political change?: Why bipartisan relevance matters. 5:17 – Where the Phoenix Principles came from: From a conservative convening to the Phoenix Declaration and the book. 8:09 – A vision of education: formation, not just job prep: Transmitting culture and forming citizens. 10:05 – The seven principles: From the primacy of parents to the formation of citizens. 12:05 – The primacy of parents and the role of the state: Federalism, the common schools and school choice as a check on the state. 18:12 – Can parents get it wrong?: Individual bad choices versus statewide ones. 21:44 – "Haggling over the price": book bans and school choice: Everyone draws a line somewhere. 26:30 – Is the Department of Education shrinking?: Why lasting change takes Congress. 29:14 – The federal tax credit program: A school choice win, and federalism concerns. 30:07 – Pluralism, transparency and illiberal bills: Classroom video and anti-DEI bills. 32:57 – An American vision, not just a conservative one: Federalists and Anti-Federalists, Marx and Smith. 35:22 – Knowledge, inquiry and the pedagogy wars: Drew on the tension in the book. 37:45 – Shared cultural knowledge and the trivialization of civics: Knowing Harry Potter trivia doesn't make you a wizard. 40:09 – Wrestling with primary sources: Malcolm X, MLK and a favorite teaching moment. 42:54 – Direct instruction and inquiry: Times and places for each. 44:29 – The pendulum swing: Drew on rigid models and rote memorization. 48:37 – In defense of memorization: Kipling, the Gettysburg Address and "Paul Revere's Ride." 51:24 – School choice as a release valve: The growth of classical education. 52:57 – What success would look like: more boring politics: Majority rule and minority rights. 57:37 – Inoculating students against tribalism: Human dignity at the core. 1:00:34 – Where to find the book: The Phoenix Principles from Encounter Books.