Five Before Five Podcast

Hamzah Henshaw

Details

Every Friday I share five ideas that blend expert insight from education, business, and health with the timeless wisdom of Islam. hamzahhenshaw.substack.com

Recent Episodes

APR 4, 2026
The Kind of Opposition Most Muslims Don’t Know How to Handle
Most Muslim communities don’t lose because they lack resources. They lose because they respond to resistance the wrong way. Not to hard opposition. Hard opposition is actually easier. You know what you’re dealing with. I’m talking about soft opposition. Polite discomfort. Procedural resistance that sounds reasonable on the surface. “We have concerns about parking.” “The schedule doesn’t allow for it.” “We’d need to review the policy.” We mishandle it almost every time. We react emotionally and defensively instead of strategically. I want to tell you a story I heard this morning during a community breakfast. It’s one I didn’t live through myself. But I inherited the result of it, and it changed how I think about many of the challenges our communities face. Al-Noor Academy, the school where I spent years helping Muslim students get into Harvard and MIT, almost didn’t get its building. ANA, the first Muslim high school in New England, had been operating out of the basement of a mosque in Quincy since its founding in 2000. Within a few years they’d completely outgrown the space and needed a proper building. They found one. The old St. Mary’s Church in Mansfield. The oldest church in town. A Catholic parish that had built a newer, bigger church nearby, leaving the original empty and up for sale. About 15,000 square feet. Exactly what they needed. But here’s what made this location especially attractive. The church was walking distance from the Mansfield commuter rail station. The Boston-to-Providence line passes right through. This would allow students coming from Boston, from Providence, from all over to get to school on their own. Working parents who didn’t have to drive 45 minutes each way. That train station was the difference between a school that was accessible and one that wasn’t. So the school expressed interest in purchasing the building. And then one man stood up. He said St. Mary’s was where his parents had gotten married. He said he was uncomfortable with it being purchased by Muslims. He wanted to “save” St. Mary’s. He petitioned. He complained. He made noise. The typical Muslim response would have been predictable. Get angry. Get self-righteous. Write op-eds. Rally the community and make it a battle about Islamophobia. But alhamdulillah, our founders had real hikmah. What they did next is something I’ve almost never seen replicated. They sat down with their lawyer and came up with a plan. They went to this man and said: Listen. This location works for us because of two things: the square footage and the walking distance from the train station. We’re not attached to the building itself. So here’s what we’ll do. We’ll give you 60 days. If you can find us another location that meets those two requirements, 15,000 square feet and walking distance from a commuter rail station, we will happily withdraw our bid. If not, we move forward. On the surface, this looked like compromise. It wasn’t. They didn’t argue with him. They didn’t try to convince him. They took an emotional objection and turned it into a practical challenge. They gave him dignity, but also responsibility. And they shifted the entire arena. It was no longer a fight about religion and identity. It was a question: Can you solve this better than we can? Meanwhile, the man took the emotional route. He went out and formed a 'Save Old St. Mary's' nonprofit and sent flyers to the entire town, trying to rally support against the sale. The school, on the other hand, did something far quieter and more strategic. They went to every faith community in Mansfield. Including the new St. Mary’s parish. They explained what they were building. What it would bring to the town. Who they were. They built relationships. One conversation at a time. The faith leaders of Mansfield—Christian, Jewish, and others—stepped up. They came out publicly and pledged their support for Al-Noor Academy. Sixty days passed. The campaign fizzled. The opposition had isolated itself. The school got the building. They never heard from that man again. They didn’t win the argument. They made the argument irrelevant. I arrived at Al Noor 6 years later. By then, the building had been transformed from a church into a bona fide school. When they renovated, they added a floor halfway up the old church, turning the upper space into a masjid with soaring ceilings that still carry the architecture of St. Mary's. Five times a day, students and the wider local community pray in a space where the old and the new exist together. But the students who went on to Harvard, MIT, and beyond, the students whose stories and strategy I helped shape, whose lives changed because someone believed in them? Those students didn't appear in a vacuum They are downstream of decisions like this one. Every institution our kids benefit from was built by someone who faced resistance and chose strategy over reaction. The building I walked into every day existed because a group of Muslim leaders chose hikmah over anger twenty years earlier. That’s institutional wisdom. And we are losing it. This pattern shows up everywhere. A student trying to get Jumu’ah accommodated at school. A parent asking the district to recognize Eid absences. A family trying to start an MSA. A community seeking a zoning variance to expand their masjid. And the instinct is always the same. Argue harder. Push back. Or give up. All three miss the point. The goal is not to win the argument. The goal is to redesign the situation so the argument collapses on its own. Absorb, don’t mirror. Shift from values to constraints. Build relationships while the other side builds campaigns. Let time do the work. Soft front. Firm back. If you know the seerah, this might sound familiar. At Hudaybiyyah, the Prophet ﷺ made an agreement that looked like a loss. Within two years, Makkah was opened. Restraint is not weakness. It is the hardest form of strength. Most people never learn how to do this. Not because it’s complicated. Because it requires something rare. Restraint when you feel completely justified in reacting. We don’t lose because we’re blocked. We lose because we take the bait. That building is where I discovered my life's calling. Helping young Muslims find their purpose, build futures that honor their deen and their ambitions, and get into colleges most people told them were out of reach. Five Before College was born inside Old St. Mary's Church, because our founders chose hikmah over hysteria. If this story resonated, I’d love to hear from you. Hit reply or leave a comment. I’m collecting stories like this one. Moments of institutional hikmah from our communities that need to be preserved before they’re forgotten. And if you have a Muslim teenager who’s starting to think about college, we’d love to meet them. Click this link and let’s explore how Five Before College can help them find their qibla, get into a school they love, and hold on to their identity in the process. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit hamzahhenshaw.substack.com
2 MIN
JUN 15, 2024
Navigating High School as a Muslim: How to Become a Beacon of Noor
Earlier this week, I was honored to be the keynote speaker at the Islamic School of Rhode Island’s 8th grade graduation. During this special occasion, I recounted a pivotal encounter from my own youth—a bus ride that occurred when I was just a few months older than them—that profoundly redirected my path by introducing me to Islam. Finally, I gave five specific tips for students on how they can safeguard their iman as they venture outside the of them Islamic school bubble. I explained how fully embracing their Islamic identity will make them magnetically attractive both to their classmates and to colleges. Please enjoy the speech and let me know your thoughts in the comments or by hitting the like button. Bismillah ir-rahman ir-rahim Assalam alaykum, It is an enormous privilege and pleasure to speak at the Islamic School of Rhode Island’s 8th grade graduation. I want to thank ISRI for inviting me and for the incredible work they do in nurturing the hearts and minds of our future leaders. Br. Mohamed Abdelrhman (Allah yarhamhu), one of the founders of ISRI, was a dear mentor of mine. He had a vision of inspiring unity among the Islamic schools of New England, and it is therefore appropriate that I, as a long-term teacher and administrator at Al-Noor Academy in Mansfield, was chosen to deliver today’s remarks. Standing here today brings back memories of my own 8th grade graduation, a time when I had no idea how dramatically my life was about to change. Little did I know a single bus ride just three months later would change the trajectory of my life forever. But more on that story in a moment. To be honest, I don’t remember my 8th grade graduation all that well. I was probably busy daydreaming about epic sleepovers and beating my top score in Donkey Kong. A few months later, I would begin at St. Mark’s School in Southborough, a boarding school that my father, grandfather, and an assorted array of cousins had attended before me. Who could have expected that within 18 months of arriving at this Christian school that I would embrace Islam and change the trajectory of my life forever? How did this happen? How did a boy whose ancestors came over on the Mayflower end up accepting a new faith at the age of 15? I'll tell you in one word: Dawa. An Unlikely Friendship When I arrived at St. Mark’s, there was only a single Muslim in my class. His name was Nabil, and he was different than anyone I had ever met. I first got to know Nabil on a bus ride on one of the first days of school back in my freshman year in 1992. He looked different than the rest of us. He was Indian, weighed about 220 lbs, and had the awkward beginnings of a beard with wispy hairs across his face. There was a lot about him that stuck out. At night, when we would be brushing our teeth with traditional toothbrushes, Nabil would be using a stick that he explained was a miswak, a sunnah of the Prophet (SAWS). He would carry a lota with him everywhere he went, eventually making us question how we could have ever thought toilet paper was sufficient. He completed a strange ritual every night before bed: running water up and down his forearms, performing an aggressive farmer’s blow, and then putting his feet in the sink! Our initial inclination was to make fun of him, but he was so charismatic that insults bounced off him like teflon. Nabil would then return to his room, leave his door slightly open, and call the athan. He had heard a hadith that even if you're a shepherd alone on a mountain pass, you should still call the athan out loud, as everyone and everything will bear witness on the Day of Judgement. As you can imagine, all these strange rituals made us curious, and we began to ask Nabil what they were all about. He explained that he was Muslim, that he believed in the same God mentioned in the Torah and the Bible. He said that each of the Prophet’s from Adam to Moses to Abraham and Jesus were bringing the same message: that there was only One God. Truth is a continuum, he said, and Islam was the updated “operating system” brought for all of humanity by Muhammad (SAWS), the final prophet of Allah. A Single Sentence That Changed Everything I'll never forget when my heart really changed, and I became convinced that Islam was the truth. We were in my friend Matthew’s dorm room, and out of the blue Nabil asked us, “Boys, do you want to hear the most valuable sentence in the world, that is weightier than the heavens and the earth?” We’d never heard a question like this before, so naturally, we were extremely curious. He then said: La ilaha illa Allah, Muhammad ar-Rasul Allah. There is no god but God and Muhammad (SAWS) is His messenger. When he said the kalima, an electric current coursed through my body. My hairs stood on end, and tears welled up in my eyes. I didn’t embrace Islam at that moment, but the seed had been planted. Within about 9 months, 3 of us, including Matthew, had become Muslim. His name is Noor ud-Deen, and he remains one of my closest friends to this day. So what is the purpose of relating this story to you today? Nabil was 14 years old when I first met him. That bus ride happened in September, just 3 months after my 8th grade graduation. You are exactly the same age as Nabil, and you have the opportunity to make just as profound a difference on the world if you make the same intention. Just like Nabil, many of you are about to leave the Muslim bubble and the cocoon of ISRI and join a high school where you may be one of the only Muslims on campus. From what Sr. Nafisa told me, your class is one of the most impressive in the history of ISRI. She told me that you are an incredibly positive and supportive group who love one another for the sake of Allah. She even mentioned that you get together to discuss hadith in your free time. MashAllah, that’s incredible! I get the sense that there are many Nabils on this stage who are ready to go out and spread khayr and barakah in the world. It wouldn’t be a graduation speech if I didn’t share a few pieces of advice. For today, I want to give you five nuggets of hard-earned wisdom that might have kept me awake at my 8th grade graduation. Each focuses on how you can protect your iman and get the most out of your high school experience. So here goes. 1) Your I Can is More Important than Your IQ. Some of you may be good students, some great, and some may struggle in school. In the long run, none of that really matters. The most successful of you is not going to be the one with the highest GPA but rather the one who believes in themselves the most. Henry Ford said, “Whether you think you can, or think you can’t, you’re right.” (x2) And the great Yoda said: “Do or do not, there is no try.” (x2) IQ is a silly measure of “intelligence” and has nothing to do with success in this world or the next. Your “I can” attitude, on the other hand, is the key to achieving great things. Set audacious, big goals that scare you, and then have the absolute conviction and yaqeen that you can achieve them. Set a 12-month goal and then figure out how to accomplish it THIS SUMMER. Why? Because you have something even more important than “I can.” You have iman. The reality is that we cannot do anything, but Allah can do everything. And He can do it through us if we set the right intention. As I always teach my students: “Believe in Allah, believe in yourself, and you can move mountains.” 2) You are the Average of the Five People You Spend the Most Time With. Having the right suhba or friend group is one of the most important ingredients to success in dunya and akhirah. You have been blessed to have each other and the amazingly supportive community of ISRI for many years. You must preserve these relationsh… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit hamzahhenshaw.substack.com
16 MIN
MAY 18, 2024
How to Take Advantage of Your Youth Before Your Old Age
There is a truism that says that youth is wasted on the young. As an educator with more than 20 years of experience in the classroom, I have had a front-row seat to watch the remarkable highs and frustrating lows of adolescence. As a college counselor at a small Islamic school and now an independent educational consultant, I have watched many cohorts of students progress through the ranks from middle to high school before navigating the college application process. There are two overlapping characteristics that define the most successful students: * A passion for reading * An intellectual curiosity that springs from within As a teacher, my least favorite questions are “Is this going to be on the test?” and “Is this graded?” Each implies a lazy reliance on the extrinsic motivation of grades. Colleges, and indeed people in general, are not looking for academic robots but are rather seeking inspirational and passionate thinkers and doers. The very first word of the Quran that was revealed to the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was “Read.” An innate passion for reading and ideas allows a select few young people to navigate the social media-infested waters and shoals of apathy in a way that keeps their pilot light of curiosity burning. But this quality is within the grasp of all. Here are five specific recommendations on how to take advantage of your youth before your old age. 1) Listen to The Magic of Thinking Big by David Schwartz It is uncanny how many world-class performers read this book when they were about 15 years old. It is a remarkably simple (if somewhat quaint) look at how an unshakeable belief that “I can do it” is the thermostat that regulates what we can accomplish in life. Most young people don’t believe they can succeed at the highest levels. So they don’t. I am constantly drilling home to my students that “Your I Can is more important than your IQ.” I always add that “Your Iman is the source of your I Can.” The reality is that we can’t do anything without the help and permission of Allah. But with His help and permission, we can do ANYTHING. Firm belief, or in Islamic terms, iman, and a vivid vision triggers the mind to figure out the how-to. 2) Read How to Be a High School Superstar by Cal Newport. This book delivers on its subtitle, “A Revolutionary Plan to Get into College by Standing Out (Without Burning Out).” Newport advocates for counterintuitive ideas like “The Law of Underscheduling.” Instead of filling their schedule with a grueling list of APs and endless extracurriculars, students should pack their schedules with free time. This grants them the freedom to pursue their true passions with a single-minded focus that allows them to become “pointy” in one or two areas of authentic interest. Top colleges are not looking for “well-rounded” students. Instead, they are seeking to build well-rounded classes of pointy individuals. By leaving enough time in your schedule to go deep and invest heavily in your top interests, you are cutting down on the stress of high school while becoming more intellectually and emotionally alive. 3) Calibrate your Qibla The Qibla is the direction of the Kaaba in Mecca that Muslims face during their daily prayers. Metaphorically, finding one’s Qibla means having a clear purpose and direction in life and doggedly working towards it. Knowingly or unknowingly, everyone is pursuing their own Qibla. Make sure you have chosen wisely. One of the reasons I love shepherding students through the college application process is that it forces them to come face to face with the age-old question: What makes you you? So many people, including most adults, are sleepwalking through life, putting out one urgent fire after the next without ever zooming out to see the 10,000 foot view of their lives. They never make the time to consider who they are and what they are trying to accomplish in life. Only about 20% of the population sets goals. And only about 15% of those who set goals write them down. Meanwhile, a Harvard Business study found that the 3% of graduates from their MBA program who had written down their goals ended up earning ten times as much as the other 97% put together, just ten years after graduation. I will be launching the next iteration of my Find Your Qibla premium group coaching course soon where I will teach students how to clarify their purpose and set ambitious goals. 4) 30 Minutes a Day: The Surprisingly Simple Way to Stand Out in the College Admissions Game As a college counselor, I get lots of questions about the most effective strategies for gaining admission to competitive colleges. It is my firm belief that dedicating 30 minutes a day for a full year to the steps below can transform high school students into compelling college candidates with a fraction of the stress faced by those who overload their plates with a grueling slate of extracurriculars. * Google any topic that piques your interest and add “Just For Dummies.” The “For Dummies” series provides a wealth of articles (and their famous books) on a wide range of topics written in easy-to-understand language. Once you have read enough of this series, you will be far from a dummy yourself. * Watch educational YouTube channels like CrashCourse or TedEd to explore topics that you are curious about. We all know YouTube will be a big part of your diet; don’t neglect to eat your fiber. * Go on a walk and listen to podcasts, especially ones like Stuff You Should Know or Everything Everywhere, which offer short snippets of high quality, high interest material. What could be better than getting exercise and expanding your mind all at once? College is a bottom-line business. One of the dirty secrets of the industry is that a large factor in admissions decisions is the future earning potential of their graduates. The creator economy is now king, and nothing predicts success in this market as clearly as genuine intellectual curiosity. Young people who somehow manage to retain their childlike wonder at how the world works and never stop asking why will rise to the top when admissions committees are meeting. 5) Don’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good. I wrote this quote in a student’s yearbook about 15 years ago. Years later, she told me it was the most profound piece of advice she had ever received. So many of us become so paralyzed by the pursuit of perfection that we end up stagnating and not being even good. One of the gifts of youth is that no one expects you to have it all figured out. Revel in this freedom, and lean into the discomfort of being a beginner. Whenever I would head off to camp in the summer, my father would send along a copy of Rudyard Kipling’s masterpiece “If.” Try to read it once a month and assess how far along you are to becoming a “man, my son.” In conclusion, harnessing the potential of youth is about cultivating a passion for reading, nurturing intellectual curiosity, setting clear and ambitious goals, and embracing the freedom to explore and learn without the fear of failure. By integrating timeless wisdom from the Quran, adopting strategic approaches from thought leaders, and dedicating just a small portion of time daily to self-improvement, young people can navigate their formative years with purpose and confidence. Let your curiosity and determination be the compass that guides you to success, both in this world and the next. Please join the thousands of readers just like you on my Five Before College email list. Every Monday and Thursday I send out college and education tips interspersed with Islamic wisdom to help teenagers succeed in this world and the next. And please hit the heart button or leave a comment to let me know what you thought about this week’s newsletter! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit hamzahhenshaw.substack.com
10 MIN
MAY 10, 2024
The Greenhouse Effect of the Muslim Bubble…and What We Can Do About It
The problem with bubbles is that they eventually burst. When this happens on playgrounds, the impact is minimal, but when bubbles burst in the housing or stock markets, the repercussions can be life-altering. Our planet is not so far off from being a bubble itself. The greenhouse effect describes how heat radiated from the Earth’s surface is trapped by greenhouse gases, thereby warming the planet. The greenhouse effect is essential to life on Earth, yet excessive greenhouse gas emissions from burning fossil fuels are causing the temperature on earth to rise dramatically. While melting polar ice caps and catastrophic climate change are not quite the same as a bubble bursting, they represent a similar threshold of irreversibility that, once crossed, could lead to drastic changes in the global environment. Bubbles and greenhouses are also apt metaphors to describe a common strategy of raising Muslim children in the west. When I taught at an Islamic school, many of the graduating seniors were “lifers,” having attended the school from pre-K to 12th grade. Their weekends consisted of hanging out with Muslim friends at Muslim events in Muslim spaces. I just returned from a week-long speaking tour in Dallas in Houston. MashAllah, the Muslim infrastructure there is truly impressive—state-of-the art masjids, 1000+ student Islamic schools with beautiful gym facilities, thoughtfully designed Muslim neighborhoods surrounding the masjids, infinite halal food options. Despite the highly developed ecosystem—or perhaps because of it—many of the young Muslims I met there seemed stuck inside of the Muslim bubble, seldom engaging with the wider world. Few students had applied for internships or had gotten any real-world work experience, and most had limited social interactions outside of their immediate community. This insular approach, akin to a greenhouse, nurtures growth in a safe, structured environment. However, just as with any protective bubble, there is a risk of a sudden burst. I vividly remember a Muslim college student being rushed to the emergency room to have his stomach pumped due to alcohol poisoning on the first weekend of college. The “greenhouse effect” of the Muslim bubble describes the phenomenon where Muslim parents create a controlled, insulated environment to nurture their children’s development while limiting their exposure to external influences in order to ensure religious and cultural continuity. Of course, many children raised outside of the Muslim bubble, are suffering even more dire consequences—loss of faith, drug use, teenage pregnancies. This begs the question— how can we strike a balance between protecting our youth within a supportive Muslim community and ensuring they are equipped to engage confidently and competently with the broader world? In short, how can we leverage the positive impact of the greenhouse effect without creating a bubble in danger of bursting. 1) Benefits of the Greenhouse Effect There is a reason that farmers use greenhouses. By creating a controlled environment where the temperature and humidity can be monitored, the growing season can be extended, and pests can be kept at bay, delicate saplings can be nurtured when they are at their most vulnerable. Similarly, there are significant benefits to raising our children within a greenhouse-like “bubble” when they are young. The solidarity Muslim children feel when growing up among like-minded peers helps them reinforce spiritual practices without feeling marginalized. Early exposure to Islamic rituals and mindsets helps cement their identities when they are most impressionable. Just as important, Muslim “greenhouses” protect children from negative influences such as drug & alcohol use, inappropriate relationships, and societal pressures toward materialism that prioritize fleeting pleasures over long-term spiritual and ethical goals. 2) Dangers of the Muslim Bubble Just as deforestation and the burning of fossil fuels release excessive greenhouse gases that threaten the health of our climate, similarly an over-reliance on the “Muslim bubble” can have detrimental effects on our children. Plants raised in greenhouses tend to have a shallow root system and are less hardy than those that grow naturally in the forest. Children raised exclusively within the Muslim bubble tend to lack resilience and develop an insular worldview. In their desire to protect their children from negative influences, some Muslim parents stunt their growth by never exposing them to real-world challenges. This overprotection fosters a dependency on constant support and shields them from failure. Children raised within the bubble don’t have to “fight” to maintain their Muslim identity and are at serious risk when they are eventually exposed to the diverse challenges of the real world. Many Muslim families insist that their children live at home even during college, further eroding an opportunity for them to develop an independent Muslim worldview. 3) Contrast with the immigrant experience The childhood experiences of children growing up within the Muslim bubble contrast sharply with those of most Muslim immigrant parents. Many Muslim parents arrived in the west with only $5 in their pockets and a dream about building a new life. With a twinkle in their eyes, they tell their children stories about their early years—cockroach-infested apartments, living on Ramen noodles, working a minimum-wage job late into the night. They look back on these hardships fondly because they were the key to their later success. Just like trees in a natural growth forest must grow deep roots to find the proper nutrients, these parents developed resilience and a strong work ethic thanks to their early struggles. By contrast, most Muslim children growing up in the bubble have faced few challenges. They often live in comfortable, well-established communities surrounded by family and community members who share similar values and experiences. While these children benefit from a sense of security that their parents may not have initially had, this “softer” environment shields them from the harsher realities of life, potentially impacting their ability to handle adversity with the same resilience demonstrated by their parents. Despite knowing that their time in the “oven” is what baked their bread, many Muslim parents seem to prefer to treat their children as delicate pastries, carefully shielding them from the intense heat of life’s challenges. 4) Islamic Perspective In Surah Ankabut, Allah asks: “Do the people think that they will be left to say, ‘We believe’ and they will not be tested?” A hadith in Sahih Bukhari states: “When Allah (SWT) desires good for someone, He tries him with hardships.” While these hardships can come to us whether we are in the Muslim bubble or not, it is instructive that Allah indicates that trials are a major source of growth. In our efforts to protect our children from fitna, we may paradoxically be making them more susceptible to the virus by not allowing them to strengthen their immune system. Just as a tree that has been raised in a greenhouse will be toppled by a strong wind, so too can our children be felled by the arrows of Shaytaan if we have never put them in an environment where they learn to build their own shield. 5) So What is the Solution? I believe that Muslim families should adopt a hybrid approach when raising their children. During their formative K-12 years, there are significant benefits to the protective shell of the Muslim bubble. When they reach the second half of high school, and certainly when they enter college, however, it is essential that our children confront the diverse perspectives and challenges of the “real world.” “Hardening off,” is a term in gardening that refers to the gradual acclimation of plants raised indoors to the harsher conditions of the outdoors. It consists of progr… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit hamzahhenshaw.substack.com
10 MIN