Between Myth and Belief

PeaPod Productions

Details

Michelle is a witch attuned to the supernatural. Beth is a skeptical secular witch. Together they explore folklore, cryptids, ghost stories, and legends from the Appalachian Mountains and beyond. Weaving faith and doubt, wonder and wit into stories that echo with mystery, they live in the space between the magical and the mundane, offering their listeners both chills and charm.

Recent Episodes

NOV 15, 2026
The Snallygaster: Maryland’s Forgotten Dragon
This week on Between Myth and Belief, Beth and Michelle dig into the Snallygaster, the cryptid dragon of Frederick County, Maryland. We trace the name back to the German Schneller Geist, or “quick ghost,” and look at the seven-pointed barn stars and hex signs said to keep it away. Then we follow the 1909 Middletown Valley Register hoax, a monster built to sell papers and inspired by the Jersey Devil craze, and look at who that monster was aimed at in a Jim Crow state. From there the legend returns in 1932 during a political upheaval and goes out in a Prohibition-era blaze of dynamite, before settling into its modern life as a local mascot. Calendar of the Weird Our rundown of mythology, spooky, cryptid, and lore events for the two-week window: 17th Annual Port Gamble Ghost Conference (Nov 6 to 8, Port Gamble, WA): a weekend of paranormal speakers, classes, and investigations in a historic 1853 mill town. https://events.humanitix.com/17th-annual-port-gamble-ghost-conference Center for Contemporary Mysticism: Fall Spiritual Retreat (Nov 14, livestream): a one-day online retreat called “The Breath Between Worlds.” https://www.eventbrite.com/e/fall-spiritual-retreat-2026-livestream-tickets-2002914726865 Cosmic Travelers Expo Spiritual Fair (Nov 14 to 15, Palmdale, CA): https://www.eventbrite.com/e/cosmic-travelers-expo-spiritual-fair-nov-14-15-2026-palmdale-ca-tickets-2001093730215 Jeff Gere: True Supernatural Tales of Hawaii (Nov 16, Menlo Park Library, Menlo Park, CA): a free storytelling event about island spirits, stones, bones, and the volcano goddess Pele, part of the Menlo Park Storytelling Festival. https://storynet.org/events/event/jeff-gere-true-supernatural-tales-of-hawaii/ Sound attributions: Rustling a newspaper.wav by isapozhnik -- https://freesound.org/s/488673/ -- License: Creative Commons 0 church-bell in city 170429_1122.wav by klankbeeld -- https://freesound.org/s/426760/ -- License: Attribution 4.0
37 MIN
OCT 31, 2026
Trick or Terror: Three Halloween Urban Legends and Creepypasta
Grab a hot cuppa, a blanket, and dim the lights. This All Hallows’ Eve, Between Myth and Belief is telling three modern urban legends and creepypasta tales about murder, memory, and blame, and we’re asking why stories like these refuse to stay buried. First, the Candy Lady of Terrell, Texas. In 1903, children begin finding candy and handwritten notes on their bedroom windowsills, and suspicion lands on Clara Crane, a real woman who was convicted of poisoning her husband and then vanished from the records. Next, Candle Cove, the legendary creepypasta about a strange local kids’ show that a handful of forum users swear they remember. Finally, a Halloween night in 1962, a house full of teenagers in homemade masks, and a photograph that may be older than the story told about it. Along the way, we talk about how childhood memory plays tricks on us, why creepypasta is basically written improv, the TV shows only we seem to remember, and what it means to believe a story because we want it to be true. Spoiler warning for our own sake: if you already know these tales, please don’t give away the endings. The photo for the last story: Then stick around for the Calendar of the Weird. Halloween may be over by midnight, but the weirdness has other plans. This fortnight brings late-night ghost hunts, celebrations honoring the dead, community rituals, and an extremely early visit from everyone’s favorite Alpine Christmas menace. Here are the events mentioned in our Calendar of the Weird: OCTOBER 31: Halloween Ghost Hunt | Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum, Weston, West Virginia. Overnight paranormal investigation, 11:30 p.m. to 6 a.m. https://trans-alleghenylunaticasylum.com/schedule-of-events/ OCTOBER 31 to NOVEMBER 1: Día de Muertos | Mano a Mano, St. Mark’s Church-in-the-Bowery, New York City. Free community altar, traditional art, performances, and remembrance. https://www.manoamano.nyc/day-of-the-dead-dia-de-muertos-nyc NOVEMBER 7: Night at the Glore Museum | American Hauntings, St. Joseph, Missouri. Limited-capacity after-hours paranormal investigation. https://www.bumpinthenight.net/ NOVEMBER 7: Día de los Muertos and Diwali Festival | Presidio Tunnel Tops, San Francisco, California. Free celebration featuring storytelling, cultural activities, and a fire ceremony. https://presidio.gov/explore/events/dia-de-los-muertos-and-diwali-festival NOVEMBER 8: 37th Annual All Souls Procession | Tucson, Arizona. A community procession and remembrance ceremony. Gathering at 4 p.m., procession at 6 p.m. https://allsoulsprocession.org/all-souls-procession-guidelines/ NOVEMBER 13 to 14: Paranormal Tour and Overnight Ghost Hunt | Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum, Weston, West Virginia. Friday tour 9:30 to 11:30 p.m.; Saturday ghost hunt 9 p.m. to 5 a.m. https://trans-alleghenylunaticasylum.com/schedule-of-events/ NOVEMBER 14: Krampus Holiday Market | Morbid Anatomy, Tom Kane Theater, Industry City, Brooklyn, New York. Oddities, gothic art, taxidermy, and Krampus-themed shopping, 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. https://www.morbidanatomy.org/events-tickets/p/krampus-market-2026-zacs2 Have a tale to tell? Email us at [email protected] or find us on Instagram and Bluesky at @mythandbelief. Follow and subscribe wherever you listen, and visit our other podcast, Cozy Quilt Cinema, at CozyQuiltCinema.com. Sounds used in episode: Halloween01.mp3 by Filax -- https://freesound.org/s/169319/ -- License: Creative Commons 0
62 MIN
OCT 19, 2026
The Church Grim: Guardians of the Graveyard
Imagine walking home down a dark Danish road in the early 1800s and meeting a lone white lamb in the fog. Now imagine counting its legs and wishing you hadn’t. This week on Between Myth and Belief, Beth and Michelle head into the churchyard to meet the Church Grim, the guardian spirit of European folklore said to watch over the dead after the mourners go home. It might be a black dog, a phantom lamb, a razor-backed galloping sow, or the last soul buried in the ground. We dig into where the Grim came from, including the old belief that something had to be buried first, whether an animal under the cornerstone or a human in the very first grave. Along the way we cover the death lamb of Ryslinge, the piglet that led a woman to a churchyard gate, and the Scottish Highland tradition of the faire chlaidh, which sent grieving families to blows over who got buried first. We also meet the drowned sailors of Danish legend and the black dogs of the Norfolk coast, and we take a Swedish Year Walk to the church door on New Year’s Eve, a journey that inspired a certain spooky indie video game. Is the Church Grim a Victorian collector’s romantic theory, a clever way to keep grave robbers away, or a very human wish that someone stay behind to watch over the people we love? Beth, your resident skeptical secular witch, lands somewhere between wild boar in a graveyard and something that’s still standing at the gate. We also take a look at what a church grim might look like in the Appalachian mountains. Calendar of the Wierd: ScareFest Weekend 2026 Lexington, KY Astrology University: Uranus in Gemini & Cosmic Resets Spooky Empire & Halloween Weekend Cons Orlando, FL
75 MIN
OCT 4, 2026
Brown Mountain Lights: Ghost Lights of the Blue Ridge
This week on Between Myth and Belief, Beth and Michelle head into the Blue Ridge Mountains to chase the Brown Mountain Lights, one of Appalachia's most stubborn ghost light legends. We start with the three stories people tell about where the lights come from: a Cherokee and Catawba battle, a faithful lantern-carrying searcher whose legend got a lot more complicated once we looked at who was telling it, and a woman named Belinda who may not be finished yet. Then the government gets involved. Two U.S. Geological Survey investigations blamed trains and car headlights, and the locals were not having it, since plenty of them swore they saw the lights before either existed. We also cover decades of cameras, an experiment with a very bright arc light, and a roadside rock shop owner whose encounter with the lights involved a crystal tunnel, the lost planet Pee-Wom, and a ride to Venus. Is it ball lightning? Piezoelectric glow from quartz in the rock? Refracted headlights bent by wet mountain air? Or something that still hasn't been explained? Beth, your resident skeptical secular witch, lands somewhere between swamp gas and magic, and explains why the stories we keep telling about this mountain matter more than the photons. Bring a flashlight. Don't touch anything glowing. Calendar of the Weird: October 4 to 17 WitchFest at Gardner Village All Month Long Monster Bash Conference Autumn 2026 October 16-18 KC Metaphysical Fair - October 17th Scream Diego 2026 - October 17th Nightmare Weekend Raleigh - October 10-11 Nightmare in Vegas 2026 - October 10-11 Midwest MonsterCon 2026 -October 9-10 Windy City Witch Fest - October 9-10 Saturn reaches opposition - October 4-6 Attributions: Hilltop_meadow_20200328.mp3 by rabban625 -- https://freesound.org/s/511088/ -- License: Creative Commons 0 Song by StockTune
47 MIN
SEP 20, 2026
Dungeon Rock: Pirate Gold, Ghosts, and Obsession
This week on Between Myth and Belief, Michelle takes Beth to Lynn, Massachusetts, and the strange story of Dungeon Rock. According to legend, pirate Thomas Veal was trapped inside the cave during a 1658 earthquake, along with a fortune in stolen treasure. Nearly two centuries later, spiritualist Hiram Marble decided he was going to find it. With help from mediums, messages supposedly sent by the dead, dynamite, chisels, and an absolutely unreasonable amount of determination, Hiram and his son Edwin spent decades tunneling through the rock in search of pirate gold that always seemed to be just a little farther away. We talk pirates, buried treasure, Spiritualism, questionable historical sources, ghostly excavation advice, and the very human ability to keep digging long after most people would have gone home. Was Thomas Veal real? Was there ever treasure inside Dungeon Rock? Were the spirits actually helping, or was Hiram simply very committed to the bit? Grab a lantern. We’re digging in. Calendar of the Weird: September 19–20 — Mothman Festival, Point Pleasant, West Virginia. The annual festival commemorates the 1966 Point Pleasant sightings, with paranormal speakers, TNT-area activities, cosplay, music, vendors and other Mothman-related events. Mothman Festival official site September 19 — International Observe the Moon Night. NASA’s worldwide lunar-observation event encourages people not only to look at the Moon, but to explore the scientific, cultural and personal connections humans have made with it—making it an easy doorway into lunar gods, monsters, omens and folklore. NASA — International Observe the Moon Night September 22 — Autumn Equinox / Mabon. The equinox occurs at 8:05 p.m. EDT on September 22. Many modern Pagans observe the season as Mabon or Harvest Home, while equinox and harvest traditions have accumulated myths concerning balance, the darkening year, death and renewal; the Persephone story is one familiar mythological association. September Equinox information Pagan Federation — September festivals September 26 — The calendar goes feral. The Harvest Moon is full that night, with Saturn appearing nearby. September 26 is also National Ghost Hunting Day, a modern paranormal observance held on the last Saturday of September. And in Van Meter, Iowa, the Van Meter Visitor Festival celebrates the town’s famous 1903 bat-like creature legend with monster walks, paranormal presentations and folklore events—which is particularly fun given that we just visited the Visitor on the podcast. NASA September 2026 skywatching guide National Ghost Hunting Day Van Meter Visitor Festival — Travel Iowa September 29 — Michaelmas and the púca's war on blackberries. Michaelmas celebrates St. Michael, traditionally depicted defeating Satan or a dragon. British and Irish folklore also warns against eating blackberries after Michaelmas: some stories blame the Devil for ruining them after being cast from Heaven, while Irish versions say the púca soils or otherwise spoils the berries. The National Folklore Collection preserves accounts in which children were explicitly warned away from post-Michaelmas berries because the púca guarded them and eating them could bring ill luck. RTÉ — Michaelmas customs and folklore Dúchas — Irish National Folklore Collection account October 2–4 — Bigfoot at the 40, Honobia, Oklahoma. Beginning October 2—so it falls inside your calendar window—the southeastern Oklahoma gathering combines Bigfoot research presentations with vendors, live music, camping and appropriately atmospheric campfire storytelling. Bigfoot at the 40 — Oklahoma Tourism Sound attribution: Rocky Road Instrumental by studioste -- https://freesound.org/s/819232/ -- License: Creative Commons 0
50 MIN