FNDN Series

Matt McFarlane

From 5% to 100%: How Todoist Fixed Feedback

NOV 14, 202654 MIN

Description

Episode Summary: Nadia joined Todoist to find something unusual: a 20-year-old company, 108 people, some there for a decade, that had never had a formal career framework. No ladder. No performance system. On purpose. Todoist had always built on first principles — egalitarian, lean, and remote-first since before remote was cool. Off-the-shelf HR tools didn't fit, so they simply didn't use them. An informal pilot kept piloting, engagement sat at 5%, and feedback like "I really liked working with Matt. Great." was as deep as it got. In this episode of FNDN Series, Nadia joins Matt to share how she rebuilt everything from the ground up. From meeting all 108 employees in her first 90 days and planting seeds instead of mandating change, to launching scrappy V1s in public using Todoist's own boards. The result: 100% completion on self, peer and manager reviews with zero nudges, a public Feedback Compass built on Radical Candor, and a 3-lane nonlinear career framework where an IC9 can earn and impact like a Head 9. They also dive into the 80/20 Lead model (80% building, 20% leading), why in-the-moment feedback beats the 6-month essay, how Todoist OS powers reviews with AI, and why shadowing — like the 6-year CX team member who became a Product Designer — might be the most underrated growth tool we abandoned. Nadia also reflects on why you should never copy-paste her framework, the art of building systems not cycles, and why bringing back shadowing could be the unlock for lean, AI-native teams. This episode is brought to you by Leapsome: https://hubs.li/Q04BRZDY0 Leapsome is the Agentic HR Platform. For lean people teams with outsized business impact. Episode Chapters 00:00 – Intro: Knowing each other forever, finally connecting 01:45 – Why Todoist had nothing for 19 years 04:20 – The 108-person listening tour in 90 days 07:10 – The pilot that kept piloting: 5% engagement and incomplete reviews 09:45 – Why off-the-shelf competencies don't scale 12:15 – Planting seeds: How to build allies before you build systems 15:00 – The 3-lane framework: IC, Lead, Head 16:40 – The 80/20 Lead: 80% building, 20% leading, not managing 19:50 – Non-linear growth when you can't promote everyone to VP 22:30 – The Feedback Compass: Open-sourcing Radical Candor 25:00 – Public gratitude vs. 1:1 constructive in Bob 27:40 – Dogfooding Todoist boards to iterate the People system 30:45 – Why all feedback goes to the person + their manager 34:00 – Killing nudges and recency bias: 2 asks a month 37:45 – In-the-moment feedback vs. the 6-month ocean of feedback 41:20 – How Todoist OS and AI actually power self-reviews 44:00 – "I don't want a book": Why top 3 beats the essay 46:30 – Advice: Start with your philosophy, not a review cycle 49:10 – Shadow programs and the CX to Product Design move 52:30 – "An MBA in 2 weeks": Shadowing GitLab's CEO 55:00 – Bring back shadowing campaign 57:15 – Outro Resources 📘 Todoist Handbook & Feedback Compass: https://todoist.com/handbook — open-source guide to how Todoist gives and receives feedback 🗄 Todoist Career Framework: https://handbook.todoist.net/s/c60cbf71-0927-4d80-acec-1bb189b70a68 — visual guide used by Nadia on the episode, provides visibility into how career progression works at Todoist 💼 HiBob: https://www.hibob.com/ — HRIS Todoist uses to run feedback and reviews https://fndnseries.fndn.com.au/podcast